Can an Infinite Potential Barrier Conserve Energy in Real Life Scenarios?

In summary: I understand how I can describe this in classic mechanic. So another question, where can I see this applicated in real life?
  • #1
dakold
15
0
I got a question about an infinite potential barrier. If a particle with a momentum p travell through an infinite potential barrier, how can the energy be conserved, thus how can the particle have the same momentum after passing the barrier? Does there exists any real life example?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
An infinitepotential barrier? If a barrier has infinite potential, the transmission probability is zero. Or to put it more precisely (since there really isn't any such thing as an infinite potential barrier), as the "height" of the barrier increases without limit, the transmission probability decreases asymptotically towards zero.

Can you give a specific example of the kind of situation you're thinking of?
 
  • #3
I’m think of a particle, with momentum p, that travels in a region there the potential is zero and comes to a place there it exist an infinite potential barrier and travels through the region and comes to a region there the potential is again zero. How can the particle after the barrier have the same momentum p?
 
  • #4
dakold said:
I’m think of a particle, with momentum p, that travels in a region there the potential is zero and comes to a place there it exist an infinite potential barrier and travels through the region and comes to a region there the potential is again zero. How can the particle after the barrier have the same momentum p?

Off the top of my head, the ONLY "infinite" potential barrier that allows a transmission is a delta function barrier. All other infinite barrier with a finite width will cause the wavefunction to be identically zero at the boundary, so no transmission!

So, do you want to rephrase your question?

Zz.
 
  • #5
Of course that can't be an infinite barrier. So the same particle as above, but the difference is that the potential is finite. How can the momentum be conserved?
 
  • #6
dakold said:
Of course that can't be an infinite barrier. So the same particle as above, but the difference is that the potential is finite. How can the momentum be conserved?

OK, so now you are changing the scenario?

This is getting rather confusing.

Zz.
 
  • #7
I understand that I have confused you. My thought was that I must have misunderstands something because of the explanations that stated above. The case that I did think of was an infinite potential barrier with a width, but if the wavefunction is zero at the boundary than the momentum can’t be conserved, or I’m a wrong? So if the momentum shall be conserved it most be a finite barrier, or?
If a particle, with momentum p, is traveling in a region with the potential is equal to zero, at some place the potential is not zero, if my thought above is correct than shall the potential be finite. After that the potential is again zero, is the momentum conserved?
 
  • #8
dakold said:
I understand that I have confused you. My thought was that I must have misunderstands something because of the explanations that stated above. The case that I did think of was an infinite potential barrier with a width, but if the wavefunction is zero at the boundary than the momentum can’t be conserved, or I’m a wrong? So if the momentum shall be conserved it most be a finite barrier, or?

You are wrong. You are forgetting that (i) this implies a reflection at the boundary and (ii) any change in momentum is due to the interaction with the potential barrier. This is no different than a classical ball-bounce-off-wall scenario!

If a particle, with momentum p, is traveling in a region with the potential is equal to zero, at some place the potential is not zero, if my thought above is correct than shall the potential be finite. After that the potential is again zero, is the momentum conserved?

Sure it is! This is because the potential field INTERACTS on the particle!

From the way you are describing this difficulty, you may want to go back and look at your classical mechanics again. I can reformulate everything you said here in terms of classical mechanics with a classical particle going into a potential field. Any change in momentum here can be entirely explained by the interaction of that particle with such a field. A comet from far away coming into the gravitational potential of a celestial body and changes its momentum. Do you see any problem in this case? That change is to be expected since it is interacting with an external field. You can easily say the same thing in the QM case.

Zz.
 
  • #9
I understand how I can describe this in classic mechanic. So another question, where can I see this applicated in real life?
 

1. What is an "Infinite potential barrier"?

An infinite potential barrier is a hypothetical concept in physics where a particle is confined to a specific region by an infinitely high potential energy barrier. This means that the particle cannot escape or move beyond the barrier, and its energy is constantly increasing as it approaches the barrier.

2. How does an infinite potential barrier affect the behavior of particles?

An infinite potential barrier affects the behavior of particles by limiting their movement to a specific region. This creates a quantized energy state for the particle, as its energy can only take on certain discrete values. It also leads to phenomena such as particle tunneling, where a particle can overcome the barrier and appear on the other side even though its energy would not allow it to do so in classical mechanics.

3. Can an infinite potential barrier exist in the real world?

No, an infinite potential barrier is a theoretical concept and cannot exist in the real world. In reality, there are always limitations to potential energy barriers, and particles can eventually overcome them with enough energy.

4. What are some applications of the concept of an infinite potential barrier?

The concept of an infinite potential barrier has applications in various fields of physics, including quantum mechanics, solid state physics, and nuclear physics. It is also used in the development of electronic devices such as quantum well lasers and superlattices.

5. How does an infinite potential barrier relate to the uncertainty principle?

An infinite potential barrier is related to the uncertainty principle in that it causes a quantization of energy states for particles, leading to uncertainty in their position and momentum. This is because the particle's energy is confined to specific values and cannot have a precise value, as predicted by the uncertainty principle.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
855
Replies
4
Views
746
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
1
Views
890
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top