Integrate dx, dy, dz: Order Matters

In summary, when integrating with multiple variables, the convention for ordering the differentials is to have the differential that appears first be the one that is integrated with respect to last. Another notation that is commonly used is to keep the integral sign and the differential together, and the integrations are done from right to left. The order of integration can also be deduced by examining the limits of integration and making sure they follow certain criteria. Some prefer to put the information on the integral itself to easily determine the order of integration.
  • #1
captain
164
0
if you put the differential dx, dy, and dz in the front of the integrand how do you order it so that it matches the order of which variable you want to integrate first?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
That depends on the "convention" you use. Most people write the differentials after the integrand but even if you write them in front the same convention is used: The differential that appears first (yes, I see your point: you want to use the one nearest the integrand, the last one, don't you) that you integrate with respect to:
[tex]\int \int \int dxdydz f(x,y,z)[/tex]
implies that you integrate with respect to x first.
 
  • #3
Another notation which I like very well is to always keep the integral sign and the dx together, sort of an operator notation:

[tex]
\int dz \int dy \int dx \,f(x,y,z)
[/tex]

The integrations are done from right to left.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
In general, unless you are given specific limits of integration, some of which involve one or two of the variables, it doesn't matter what order you use. If the limits of integration involve variables, you can deduce the correct order of integration by: the limits of integration on the final integral (the one done last) must be constant and the limits of integration on the second integral cannot involve the variable with respect to which is being integrated nor the variable used in the first integral. Of course, to use that you have to be able to decide what variable goes with what limits of integration. That is why, I expect, Pere Callahan prefers the form where each variable is next to its limits of integration.

I personally prefer to put that information on the integral itself. For example
[tex]\int_{x= yz}^z\int_{z= 0}^1\int_{y= z}^{z^2} f(x,y,z)dxdydz[/itex]
I can tell, no matter how "dxdydz" is written, that the "outer integral" is with respect to z since its limits of integration are constants, that the "middle integral" is with respect to y since its limits of integration depend only on z and that the "inner integral" is with respect to x since its limits of integration depend on both y and z.
 

1. What is the order of integration when solving for dx, dy, dz?

The order of integration when solving for dx, dy, dz depends on the type of integral being solved. For single integrals (integrals with only one variable), the order of integration is typically from the outermost variable to the innermost variable. For double integrals (integrals with two variables), the order of integration is typically from the "outside" variable to the "inside" variable. For triple integrals (integrals with three variables), the order of integration is typically from the "outside" variable to the "inside" variable.

2. What happens if the order of integration is changed?

If the order of integration is changed, the result of the integral may also change. This is because changing the order of integration can result in a different set of limits of integration, which can alter the value of the integral. It is important to carefully consider the order of integration when solving an integral to ensure an accurate result.

3. Are there any specific rules for changing the order of integration?

Yes, there are some specific rules for changing the order of integration. For example, when changing the order of integration for double integrals, the inner limits of integration must be constants, while the outer limits of integration can be variables. Additionally, when changing the order of integration for triple integrals, the innermost limits of integration must be constants, while the outer limits of integration can be variables.

4. Can the order of integration affect the complexity of the integral?

Yes, the order of integration can affect the complexity of the integral. In some cases, changing the order of integration can simplify the integral and make it easier to solve. However, in other cases, changing the order of integration can make the integral more complex and difficult to solve. It is important to carefully consider the order of integration when solving an integral to determine the most efficient approach.

5. How can I determine the correct order of integration for a given integral?

The correct order of integration for a given integral can be determined by considering the limits of integration and the variables present in the integrand. It is important to choose an order that allows the limits of integration to be expressed as constants and the integrand to be written in terms of the "outside" variable. Practice and experience with solving integrals can also help in determining the correct order of integration.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
162
Replies
1
Views
931
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
276
Replies
3
Views
1K
Back
Top