Integral of a Sqrt

I try to take the integral of sqrt(4x-1) with respect to x...


The correct answer is sqrt((4x-1)^3)/6, but I always get

2sqrt((4x-1)^3)/3... Can someone explain how to solve that integral pls.
 

Tom Mattson

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
5,453
21
Originally posted by PrudensOptimus
I try to take the integral of sqrt(4x-1) with respect to x...
OK

The correct answer is sqrt((4x-1)^3)/6,
No, it isn't.

Edit: My mistake; yes it is.

but I always get 2sqrt((4x-1)^3)/3...
That's not right either.

Can someone explain how to solve that integral pls.
Yes, you do a u-substitution. Let u=4x-1, so du=4dx. You then have:

(1/4)∫u1/2du,

which is elementary.
 
Last edited:
21
0
If you didn't understand what the last person said when you take the integral of squrt(4x-1) with respect to xdx you must first find u and u prime (or the derivative of u), where u is what is in the parentheses, in this case (4x-1) so u prime (or the derivative of (4x-1)) = 4x, but you still have to deal with the remaining x and the 4 left by the derivative. To get rid of the 4 in the derivative you divide the integral by 4, and subistute for the x so. x=(u-1)/4, I'm you understand the rest. You multiply u^(1/2)*((u-1)/4) then take the antiderivative of that.
 

HallsofIvy

Science Advisor
41,626
821
The problem, by the way, is NOT the square root! You can easily integrate ∫ √(x) dx. √(x)= x1/2 and you can use the "power rule".
The problem is that "4x-1" inside the square root. To get rid of that you make the substitution mentioned earlier: u= 4x-1 so that
√(4x-1)= &radi;(u)= u1/2. Of course, you have to convert from "dx" to "du". Because 4x-1 is linear, that's easy
du/dx= 4 so du= 4 dx or (1/4)du= dx.

∫ &radic(4x-1)dx= (1/4)&int u1/2du.

The power rule says that an anti-derivative of un is
1/(n+1) un+1. In this case, n= 1/2 and n+1= 3/2. The anti-derivative is (2/3)u3/2+ C . Replacing u by 4x-1 again, ∫ &radic(4x-1)dx= (2/3)(4x-1)3/2+ C.

Since the original problem was given in terms of √ rather than a 1/2 power, it might be a good idea to set the answer in those terms: ∫ &radic(4x-1)dx= (2/3)(√(4x-1))3+ C.
 
279
1
Why can't you just int. the bracket like you would int. x^0.5?

Code:
∫ (4x-1)^0.5 dx

increase the power and divied by it:

(4x-1)^1.5 + c = 2(√(4x-1))^3 + c
----------       ------------
   1.5                3
 
Last edited:
144
2
Why can't you just int. the bracket like you would int. x^0.5?
Because if you differentiate your result ((2/3)(4x-1)^(3/2) + C) you get:

4(4x - 1)(1/2)

which is not what you integrated.
 

Tom Mattson

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
5,453
21
Originally posted by lavalamp
Why can't you just int. the bracket like you would int. x^0.5?

Code:
∫ (4x-1)^0.5 dx

increase the power and divied by it:

(4x-1)^1.5 + c = 2(√(4x-1))^3 + c
----------       ------------
   1.5                3
As Sting said, when you differentiate your result, you do not get the original integrand. That is because (4x-1)1/2 is a composition of functions.

f(u)=u1/2
u(x)=4x-1

In general, a composition of functions does not satisfy the same basic integration rule as the simple function f(u).

edit: typo
 
279
1
Sorry, I meant to integrate it as a sight integral, where a multiple of the differential of the bracket appears outside the bracket, ie:

∫ f'(x) * (f(x))^n dx

in this case f(x)=4x-1 and f'(x)=4. The mulitple in this case is 0.25 which you can take out of the integral and put it back in at the end to get the right answer:

Code:
1 * (4x-1)^1.5 + c = (√(4x-1))^3 + c
-   ----------       ------------
4      1.5                6
 
Lavalamp,
That's how I learned to do it, way back in '87. I think it's much quicker and easier.
Aaron
 
279
1
I only learnt about integration at the end of 2002, and then I only learnt about sight integrals earlier this year. That's why I messed up the integration the first time round.
 

The Physics Forums Way

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top