B Is the car accelerating?

361
9
As I was driving I was wondering if there is way to know if the other cars on the road accelerating. I think that if I were travelling at a constant, then if the rate at which the distance my car and another car was changing was not constant, then the other car would be accelerating. But is there any easier way?
 
898
223
Match their motion with your motion.
 

jbriggs444

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,512
2,564
As I was driving I was wondering if there is way to know if the other cars on the road accelerating. I think that if I were travelling at a constant, then if the rate at which the distance my car and another car was changing was not constant, then the other car would be accelerating. But is there any easier way?
Using the above procedure, if a car is driving circles around you, [you would decide] it is not accelerating.

Edit: clarification of intended meaning inserted
 
Last edited:
3,729
410
You could try to keep the distance constant and see if you are accelerating or not.
 

Khashishi

Science Advisor
2,806
490
Can you just look at them move? If they are turning, or speeding up, or slowing down they are accelerating.

You can look at the way the drivers lean. People lean in the direction of acceleration to stay balanced. If they have one of those air fresheners or toys hanging from their rear-view mirror, you can look at the way that moves. It will swing away from the direction of acceleration.

If you keep the same distance and heading to them, then you can feel if you are accelerating by the fictitious forces you feel.
 

davenn

Science Advisor
Gold Member
8,771
5,846
Using the above procedure, if a car is driving circles around you, it is not accelerating.
not sure if you were pointing out an error in the OP's understanding ?

Because of course, an object with a circular motion is undergoing acceleration ... the car doing the circles around you
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,154
1,729
not sure if you were pointing out an error in the OP's understanding ?

Because of course, an object with a circular motion is undergoing acceleration ... the car doing the circles around you
I wondered the same thing. Upon reflection, I conclude that, yes, he is pointing out a flaw in the OP's method.

A car going in circles around you, is neither moving away nor toward you, thus the OP would (erroneously) conclude it is not accelerating.

It's a bit contrived though. He did say "other cars on the road". Doing circles around you would be quite an edge case.
 
Last edited:
361
9
Yeah that is a good point. I know any car changing direction would be accelerating. But I am wanting to know how to determine if a car travelling in a straight line in the lane beside me is accelerating. For example, if a car in the lane beside me which was initially in my blind spot rushes ahead of my car while remaining in its lane, how would I know whether the car was travelling at a very high speed from the beginning or it suddenly accelerated?
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,154
1,729
... if a car in the lane beside me which was initially in my blind spot rushes ahead of my car while remaining in its lane, how would I know whether the car was travelling at a very high speed from the beginning or it suddenly accelerated?
Now that is a very different question.

(In practical terms - if this hypothetical scenario involves a real life moving violation - it doesn't matter which. You are obliged to be sure the lane is clear - They have right-of-way. If you pulled in front of another car, you did not make sure the lane was clear. But I digress.)
 
361
9
I am not saying they're passing me. The car would remain in the lane beside me as it sped forward.

My question remains, how would I determine if the car was accelerating or not?
 
898
223
Well your in your car, see if the speedo changes it's on the dashboard.
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,154
1,729
I am not saying they're passing me. The car would remain in the lane beside me as it sped forward.
These two statements directly contradict each other.
 

davenn

Science Advisor
Gold Member
8,771
5,846
I am not saying they're passing me. The car would remain in the lane beside me as it sped forward.
but you did state they were passing you

For example, if a car in the lane beside me which was initially in my blind spot rushes ahead of my car while remaining in its lane,

how would I know whether the car was travelling at a very high speed from the beginning or it suddenly accelerated?
I don't think you can, unless you observed earlier/prior motion of the other car

velocity is a vector comprised of speed and direction
Acceleration can be defined as a change in either of those

take my earlier comment .... an object ( car or whatever or a planet around the sun) travelling in a circular motion is accelerating, even if the speed is the same the velocity isn't because the direction is changing

the car in the lane beside you may not be changing direction, but if the speed is changing, then the velocity is changing and therefore there is an acceleration


Dave
 
686
172
The car would remain in the lane beside me as it sped forward.
If you were moving at highway speed and the other car "sped forward", or sped by you, I would say it is likely that he had a fairly significant speed delta relative to you initially. There are exceptions, but at freeway speeds most cars are not able to accelerate very quickly due to various factors (wind resistance, gearing ratio). If he was sitting in your blind spot matching your speed for even a short time, and his car had a lot of power, he could have accelerated relatively quickly. But even so, the distance from your blind spot to a position where you could see him out your window is a relatively short distance. So even a fairly powerful car could not accelerate a great deal in that short of a distance. If he was accelerating hard, were you able to hear his engine roaring? Then again, I suppose the reason you are asking is that this was some kind of a traffic incident, in which case you (or the person involved) probably didn't hear him.

Obviously, if it was at lower speeds on city streets, the other car could accelerate more quickly. But even if he did accelerate quickly, if this is a "who's at fault" kind of issue, I'm sorry to say it, but I don't think you have a good case if you changed lanes and hit him. Then again, I'm just speculating as to why you are asking about this.

If you were shown a very short snapshot in time (a very small fraction of a second) of another car relative to your car, you could probably estimate its distance from you fairly accurately. But if you were asked to estimate acceleration, or even speed, you would need to observe it for a longer time to be able to observe change over time. When I had the opportunity to use a radar gun, it had an audible tone that increased or decreased pitch as the car's speed increased or decreased.
 
361
9
Ok. Just to clarify there was no traffic incident, this was just question that popped in my mind. I was just wondering if there a visual way to determine if an object is accelerating when you yourself are in moving reference frame. I guess there is not.
 

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor
Gold Member
23,292
3,806
I was just wondering if there a visual way to determine if an object is accelerating when you yourself are in moving reference frame. I guess there is not.
There is a fairly straightforward way (easy to describe, at least, but not so convenient to implement). You need to be able to measure the bearing, velocity and range of the other car over time and also the bearing, range and velocity of a point on the road over time (both in your reference frame). This will yield what the other car is doing in the Earth's frame. Not easy for the car driver but achievable by a passenger with a hand held speed-check device (LASCAR, for instance) and a hand bearing compass. If you can't measure range directly (LASCAR forbidden) then you would need a parallax method (as in astronomy) using the change of angle subtended between local and distant points and the speed over the ground and heading of your car (heavy!).
This is a similar problem to that which was encountered with early Marine Radar systems which, originally, just showed bearing and range of another ship. With no other information than what you saw on the Radar display, both ships could spiral in towards each other, whilst faithfully following the 'pass Port to Port' rule. (see Radar Assisted Collision). But they didn't know where they actually were; in your car, you (hopefully) do.
 

davenn

Science Advisor
Gold Member
8,771
5,846
I was just wondering if there a visual way to determine if an object is accelerating when you yourself are in moving reference frame. I guess there is not.
of course there is.... do some visual and timing measurements
measure the time taken for your car and the other car to move between successive sets of road markers or power poles.
compare their time with your time.
If their time is decreasing or increasing between sets, they have positive or negative acceleration.
If their time doesn't change, they have a steady velocity

the same for your car
 

CWatters

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
10,528
2,291
Presumably this is just one of the issues that driverless car systems have to handle.
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,567
1,468
287
19
when the car next to you is matching your speed, you can be braking or accelerating and you will know if its accelerating if you are accelerating. (your spedo is going up)... without a speedo, you need to monitor the rate of change of the things around you . after all, acceleration is the rate of change of speed.
 

jbriggs444

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,512
2,564
after all, acceleration is the rate of change of speed.
You probably meant to say the rate of change of velocity.
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"Is the car accelerating?" You must log in or register to reply here.

Related Threads for: Is the car accelerating?

Replies
6
Views
19K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
3K
D
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
10K
  • Posted
Replies
15
Views
12K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top