1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Isotropic tensor functions

  1. Nov 4, 2006 #1

    I consider only Cartesian tensors in the following. The definition of
    isotropic tensor function I know is

    1) T = F ( G )

    such that, for any rotation ( ' = transpose),

    2) O F( G ) O' = F( O G O' )

    But, if I change to component notation, it seem to me that any tensor
    function is isotropic, which cannot obviously be. Denoting the
    components in the new basis with ^*, I have

    3a) T_ij^* = O_ir T_rs (O_sj)'

    3b) G_ij^* = O_ir G_rs (O_sj)'

    since T and G are tensors. Then, by 1),

    4a) T_rs = F_rs ( G_mn )

    4b) T_rs^* = F_rs^* ( G_mn^* )

    Then, substituting 3a) and 3b) into 4b), I get

    5) O_ir T_rs (O_sj)' = F_rs^* ( O_mk G_kl (O_ln)' )

    Finally, substituting 4a) into 5), I have

    6) O_ir F_rs ( G_mn ) (O_sj)' = F_rs^* ( O_mk G_kl (O_ln)' )

    that is,

    O F( G ) O' = F (O G O' )

    So any tensor function would be isotropic. Clearly that's false, but I
    don't see where the error is. Can you help me find it? Thanks,

  2. jcsd
  3. Feb 11, 2009 #2
    Here's an example of a tensor valued, anisotropic function

    [tex]H = g(T) = (T\cdot{n\otimes{n}})n\otimes{n}[/tex]
    where n is a fixed unit vector.

    g(QTQ^T) = (QTQ^T\cdot{n\otimes{n}})n\otimes{n} = (T \cdot (Q^Tn \otimes Q^Tn)) n\otimes{n}
    which is not the same as
    Qg(T)Q^T = (T\cdot{n\otimes{n}})Qn\otimes{Qn}
    for general orthogonal Q, only if n is a proper vector of Q.
    Im basically extrapolating from Jaunzemis' Continuum Mechanics book, pg 287.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook