Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Israel Media Watch

  1. Nov 24, 2003 #1
    Watching Israel's Media: Freedom of speech in the dock_

    Yisrael Medad and Eli Pollak
    Nov. 23, 2003

    What role does freedom of speech really play in Israel?

    One week after the High Court of Justice allowed the broadcast of the
    viciously anti-Israel pseudo-documentary Jenin, Jenin, representatives of
    the State Prosecutor's office appeared in the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court
    to argue for the harshest sentences possible in the case of the non-licensed
    Arutz 7 radio network.

    The prosecution asked for prison sentences for four defendants, including
    Shulamit Melamed; fines of hundreds of thousands of shekels for Rabbi Ze'ev
    Melamed, Ya'acov Katz, and Hagai Segal; and smaller fines for French
    department head David Shapira and broadcaster Gideon Sharon.

    The reasoning behind the request for such harsh sentences was that Arutz 7
    had broadcast for over 15 years, and the defendants are "leaders" who must
    serve as an example.

    We should recall that not one plane fell from the sky due to Arutz 7's
    broadcast signal, nor was it ever proven that the signal interfered with
    Ben-Gurion Airport, as claimed by the authorities. Arutz 7 has
    conscientiously paid royalties to all songwriters, while Israel Radio's
    local stations have not for the past decade. Among the people who have had
    regular programs on Arutz 7 are chief rabbis, the Knesset Speaker, cabinet
    ministers, MKs, leading lawyers, professors, thinkers, and more.

    That the attorney-general and state prosecutor ignore almost 150 other
    non-licensed stations indicates that a very_ __ specific lesson is intended
    for the religious-nationalist camp.
    Part of that lesson, it would appear, is that Attorney-General Elyakim
    Rubinstein is willing to be lenient what it suits him and to behave
    otherwise when it doesn't. He has consistently declared that the less he
    involves the application of criminal procedure in matters of political
    divisiveness the better.

    For example, in the matter of the Wakf digs on Temple Mount, he received
    letters pointing out that the destruction of its archeological treasures was
    unlawful and violated, at the very least, the Antiquities Law and Law of
    Planning. His response was to do nothing in public.

    In a more recent instance, when it was claimed that Yossi Beilin was in
    direct violation of Paragraph 97 of the Penal Code in acting to extricate
    territory from Israel's sovereignty, he again insisted that this was an
    issue for public debate, not the courtroom.

    WHAT MAKES the case of Arutz 7 different? Is the Telegraph Law, which bans
    non-licensed radio stations, really that crucial to the state's legal
    fabric?

    We should not forget that as per the Oslo Accords, several radio broadcast
    channels were handed over to the Palestinian Authority. The performance of
    these stations has been undemocratic if not downright inciting. The IDF has
    even bombed these stations out of existence or knocked out their antennas.
    As far as we are aware, Arutz 7 has not been charged with any similar
    activities.
    So why all the fuss?

    The answer lies in the realization that the media, especially the electronic
    media which is for the most part free and easily available, is a pillar of
    society. The ability to affect society, shape its opinions, and provide it
    with information and the ability to choose_ these are the real powers of
    the media.

    To our regret, Israeli society is poorly served media-wise. The field is
    plagued by bias, political interference, journalistic unprofessionalism and
    a lack of pluralism.
    Israel does not have even one independent, private news outlet among its
    broadcast media. Army Radio and the Israel Broadcast Authority are
    governmental.

    The regional radio stations are not permitted to present their own news
    service. Channel 2 TV's news is run by its news company, which is
    government-controlled. Arutz 7 was the only truly private broadcaster of
    news in this country.

    The Telegraph Law is clearly an excuse for silencing an independent news
    outlet. What is really at issue is freedom of speech in its true sense. Had
    we been a truly liberal country, we would have found a way for Arutz 7 and
    its counterparts to continue broadcasting.

    The writers are, respectively, board member and chairman of Israel's Media
    Watch (IMW). info@imw.org.il

    http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull&cid
    =1069487632637
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Nov 24, 2003 #2
    Israel's Media Whitewash

    Posted by David Ben-Ariel:

    “To our regret, Israeli society is poorly served media-wise. The field is
    plagued by bias, political interference, journalistic unprofessionalism and
    a lack of pluralism.
    Israel does not have even one independent, private news outlet among its
    broadcast media. Army Radio and the Israel Broadcast Authority are
    governmental.”

    I think that’s about the most sensible thing you’ve said yet.

    “What role does freedom of speech really play in Israel?”

    The same role it plays in most nations on itty-bitty Earth now. It is the role of propaganda to saturate the minds of us cattle-humans and keep the ruling elite in power. From speaking to conscientious objectors to Israeli military drafts, I’d say VERY LITTLE. Freedom of Speech is essential for any “purported” democracy, but it doesn’t exist in Israel. If one causes to much of a stir (by this I mean people actually pay attention to your ranting), Mossad always make one “disappear”. It doesn’t matter if you’re in Israel or Australia, those clowns will “come-a-lookin”. I remember when Vanunu (I think that was his name) spilt the truth on Israel’s Nuclear program in the late 80s. The poor bastard sought sanctuary in Australia from the government and ASIO, and his reward was to be betrayed by Australia and the entire world. Mossad marched into Australia (like they had ANY right!) and kidnapped him. That’s Israeli Freedom of Speech for you. He’s still alive and imprisoned in Israel (for telling the world about the Zionist bomb).

    One more thing David Ben-Ariel;
    I notice that the profile directly under your name states that you are from Toledo, Ohio, USA/Menashe. Is Menashe a real place? Or, is that just a play on “Ari Ben-Menashe”, the former Mossad agent who wrote the classic expose on the criminal and terrorist activities of that agency, entitled “Profits Of War”. I still own a copy of this book, which revealed to the world the scam of PROMIS and the Robert Maxwell connection. Menashe used to be a hero of mine, that was until his latest exploits (this year!) for that British mercenary organisation (which I shall not name) which was paid to take out the leading runner in the democratic election of an African nation. I assume he’s back working for Mossad.
     
  4. Nov 24, 2003 #3
    Re: Israel's Media Whitewash

    [QUOTE
    I notice that the profile directly under your name states that you are from Toledo, Ohio, USA/Menashe. Is Menashe a real place? ][/QUOTE]

    Hey Dogon (is that dog gone or Dagon or neither?),
    USA/Menashe are one and the same. I am one of the growing number of people who are recognizing and embracing the Israelite origins of the Anglo-Saxon and Northwest European peoples. The white Euro-Americans, especially those of English descent, are predominately the biblical tribe of Manasseh, son of the patriarch JOSEPH (sold into slavery by his jealous brethren and yet became prime minister of Egypt and fed 'em all during the famine). Manasseh is the English form of the Hebrew Menashe. So I'm advertising our ROOTS. Further proof of that can be found at www.britam.org or http://www.thetrumpet.com/geo/na/docs/Literature.asp?view=Toc&id=34

    I see you're from the Land Down Under the Milky Way. Sounds great! I'd love to visit there, as well as New Zealand and everywhere else down there I'm reading about in Paul Theroux's book, The Happy Isles of Oceania - Paddling the Pacific. An English girl who used to hitchhike with me through Europe and we lived throughout Israel, as friends and volunteers on various kibbutzim, married our Aussie roommate and now lives in Brisbane!
     
  5. Nov 25, 2003 #4

    drag

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Re: Re: Israel's Media Whitewash

    Couldn't you believe in Hindu or Tao or something like that
    instead, they've so much better religions than
    those in the western and middle-eastern worlds.
    And it's healthier IQ-wise. :wink:
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?



Similar Discussions: Israel Media Watch
  1. Is Israel 'special'? (Replies: 58)

  2. Media & Politics (Replies: 44)

  3. The Israel Lobby (Replies: 29)

  4. Independence of Israel (Replies: 31)

Loading...