(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Just took calc 3 "semifinal"

And I have a few questions regarding concepts, which was sparked by a conversation with a few classmates after the test.

1st, a problem was given to us and we were asked if stokes or divergence applies. It was a line integral, so divergence did not apply.

It said that C is a "closed loop". Everything else was textbook stokes. So I wrote that stokes applied.

However, one of my classmates told me that a "closed loop" may cross its own boundary and thus doesn't enclose a single surface so stokes does not apply. I honestly did not think of that. What do you think? I think "closed loop" implies a loop, a single loop, that doesn't cross its self but I just go by how I define the word "loop." I have no mathematical reason.

The last part of our test was nested things like "grad(div F)" and we were simply to write if these were a vector, scalar, or neither (nonsensical.)

At the end, a question was asked "which of these is always zero?" I only had two of these nested functions as scalars, div(grad f) and div(curl F). Doing a bit of thinking, I figured the former came down to second derivatives, which isn't necessarily 0, so I picked div(curl F).

However, an engineering major told me that it was definitely grad(grad F) because the first grad gives you a perpendicular vector, so a vector perpendicular to that is parallel to the original (???).

I don't understand his logic at all. Gradient is del(scalar field) which is a vector field itself. Thus I put neither for grad(grad f) and didn't even consider it, because by our definitions the gradient of a vector doesn't make sense. That's not tackling his reasoning about the parallel => 0 thing..

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Just took calc 3 semifinal

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**