Lagrangian Method- 1st form? Zwangskraefte?

In summary, the conversation is about using Lagrangians in mechanics to solve problems involving particles moving on a constrained surface. The main issue is coming up with the Lagrangian for a particle moving on the inside of a paraboloid described in cylindrical coordinates. The conversation also touches on finding the size and direction of constraint forces, as well as the requirement for energy and rotational momentum to be conserved. Suggestions for approaching the problem and resources for help are also mentioned.
  • #1
clumsy9irl
7
0
Lagrangian Method-- 1st form? Zwangskraefte?

Mechanics will be the death of me. For some reason, I can do E&M, and particle stuff, but give me a pendulum, and I'm dumbfounded.

THat said, I'm working on some problems using Lagrangians, and the only book I have available to me is Goldstein (which is a bit above where I'm at, but helpful, once it clicks). The course I'm taking will count as my uppper level, undergrad mechanics course.

Anyway, I've got a problem. Supoose you have a particle that's moving frictionless in a gravitational field on the inside of a paraboloid (which is described in cylindrical coordinates as r= az.

How do I come up with the Lagrangian for this? If given one, I can usually figure out more on how to solve this, but it's stumping me. And another thing, I can't figure out what the english term for 'zwangskraft' would be, forced force? I'm supposed to find the size and direction of these forces, but I'm not really sure what it means. Eeep.


There's a note saying that I'm supposed to make it a requirement that energy and rotational momentum are conserved.

THat isn't heling me at all. Suggestions? ANy other suggestions for texts (that aren't too expensive), that might help me? My exam is in 3 weeks, and I'm lost.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
clumsy9irl said:
Supoose you have a particle that's moving frictionless in a gravitational field ...
This seems to hint that the problem has a reduced number of dimensions (from 3). In other words, you aparently have a particle confined on some surface. The frictionless stipulation tells you that the Euler Lagrange expression is equation to zero (which gives you the Euler Lagrange equation).




clumsy9irl said:
... on the inside of a paraboloid (which is described in cylindrical coordinates as r= az.
This seems to be a description of the submanifold onto which the particle is constrained to move. However, that equation doesn't look like a paraboloid to me? In fact, I am even more confused about the bold vs. non-bold.




clumsy9irl said:
How do I come up with the Lagrangian for this?
It's hard to say without a better understanding of the physical situation (because Lagrangian are Taylor-made). I will try to give you a general approach:

If this paraboloid is a 2-D surface, then devise some 2-D coordinate system that is capable of unambiguously describing the position of the particle on this surface. It is usually a good idea to do this so that either the kinetic energy or the potential energy only depends on one of the coordinates and not the other. Then, you need to express the two energies in terms of these new coordinates: T = (1/2)mv2 -> ?, V = mgh -> ?. Finally, of course, L = T - V.

If this is a 1-D parabolic curve, then the same as above, except that you don't worry so much about the coordinate dependence of T and V. You still need to express both in terms of the 1 coordinate that you chose. For instance, suppose the parabola is y = x2. Then
V = mgy = mg(x2)
and
T = (1/2)m{vx2 + vy2}
= (1/2)m{vx2 + 2xvx2}
= (1/2)m{1 + 2x}vx2

I'm not clear on what your submanifold is, though.




clumsy9irl said:
... I can't figure out what the english term for 'zwangskraft' would be, forced force? I'm supposed to find the size and direction of these forces, but I'm not really sure what it means.
From the sound of it, I would guess it means "constraint force." This is the same basic idea as the normal force you deal with in 1st semester physics. You don't approach the problem knowing it. In fact, the value doesn't matter to you except that it necessarily counteracts (usually) the weight (and any inertial forces) to balance the force and keep the particle on your submanifold. (In fact, this is just about the most important idea behind the Lagrangian formalism.)

You might try
www.dictionary.com/translator[/URL]




[QUOTE=clumsy9irl]There's a note saying that I'm supposed to make it a requirement that energy and rotational momentum are conserved.[/QUOTE]Well, you have problably have two mechanical energies: kinetic and potential. Since there's no friction, these should be conserved. The rotational momentum is conserved because you're dealing with forces that have a (scalar) potential energy associated with them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
Must be [tex]r^2=az[/tex]

Unless it's a conical surface.
 
  • #4
German has such a delightfully(?) dictatorial ring to it..
"Zwangskräfte" means, (in non-physics), "forces of subjugation"..:wink:
 
  • #5
Yes, r^2= az. Typo that happened when bolding. Sorry :(

But thank you very much for your response. THat's exactly what I need, more of a step by step thought process on how to solve a problem like this. It all seems a bit clearer now :)
 

What is the Lagrangian Method?

The Lagrangian Method is a mathematical approach used to analyze the motion of a system by considering its energy, rather than the forces acting upon it. It is often used in physics and engineering to model complex systems and make predictions about their behavior.

How does the Lagrangian Method work?

The Lagrangian Method involves defining a mathematical function called the Lagrangian, which describes the energy of the system in terms of its position and velocity. The equations of motion can then be derived by finding the minimum or maximum value of the Lagrangian with respect to the system's variables.

What is the first form of the Lagrangian Method?

The first form of the Lagrangian Method is also known as the Euler-Lagrange equations. It involves finding the equations of motion by setting the derivative of the Lagrangian with respect to each variable equal to zero. This results in a set of differential equations that describe the system's motion.

What are Zwangskraefte?

Zwangskraefte, also known as constraint forces, are forces that arise due to the constraints imposed on a system. These forces are necessary to maintain the system's configuration and are often included in the Lagrangian function when using the Lagrangian Method.

What are some applications of the Lagrangian Method?

The Lagrangian Method has many applications in physics and engineering. It is commonly used in classical mechanics to study the motion of particles and rigid bodies. It has also been applied to fields such as quantum mechanics, electromagnetics, and fluid mechanics.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
25
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
586
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
13K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Back
Top