- #1

- 319

- 0

I can't do the Wronskian on this one since y2 is not differentiable at 0, is there any other way to do this?

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Thread starter physicsss
- Start date

- #1

- 319

- 0

I can't do the Wronskian on this one since y2 is not differentiable at 0, is there any other way to do this?

- #2

lurflurf

Homework Helper

- 2,440

- 138

It is easy to see that they are linearly independent, as one is even and one is odd (I presume you mean for all real numbers).physicsss said:

I can't do the Wronskian on this one since y2 is not differentiable at 0, is there any other way to do this?

A similar approch would be to notice (ie with wronskian) that they are dependent on (-infinity,0] and [0,infinity) then show that sets of coefficients that make them linearly dependent in each region have nothing in common.

A third way is show that if

u*y1+y2=0

u is not constant

All three of these are basically the same.

say

f(x)=f(-x)

g(x)=-g(-x)

if

a f(x)+b g(x)=0

then

a f(-x)+b g(x)=0

so

a f(x)-b g(x)=0

thus

a f(x)=0

b g(x)=0

This holds for all x

f(x),g(x) cannot be zero every where

thus a=b=0 and f and g are linearly independent

Last edited:

- #3

- 319

- 0

In the book, they did something the likes of:

suppose k1 and k2 are two constants, and k1(3t)+k2(|t|)=0, then choose two points t0 and t1 where t1 is not equal to t0, if the determinant of the coefficients is not zero than the two functions are independent.

but when I did it out, they are zero for t>1 and t<1. I'm confused, I guess, since I don't understand why the determinant thing is true...

(See the picture for what I did)

suppose k1 and k2 are two constants, and k1(3t)+k2(|t|)=0, then choose two points t0 and t1 where t1 is not equal to t0, if the determinant of the coefficients is not zero than the two functions are independent.

but when I did it out, they are zero for t>1 and t<1. I'm confused, I guess, since I don't understand why the determinant thing is true...

(See the picture for what I did)

Last edited:

- #4

lurflurf

Homework Helper

- 2,440

- 138

A fourth way.physicsss said:In the book, they did something the likes of:

suppose k1 and k2 are two constants, and k1(3t)+k2(|t|)=0, then choose two points t0 and t1 where t1 is not equal to t0, if the determinant of the coefficients is not zero than the two functions are independent.

but when I did it out, they are zero for t>1 and t<1. I'm confused, I guess, since I don't understand why the determinant thing is true...

(See the picture for what I did)

The determinant tell us if the linear system

3k1*t0+k2*|t0|=0

3k1*t1+k2*|t1|=0

has a unique solution

we know k1=k2=0 is a solution

If the determinat is zero every where the system is linearly dependent.

If the determinat is ever nonzero the system is linearly independent.

you found

3(t0|t1|-t1|t0|)=3|t0|*|t1|(sign(t0)-sign(t1))

so the determinant will be nonzero if t0*t1<0

for example if t0=3 t1=-7

the determinant is 42

so linearly independant

I find this method a bit odd for this problem.

It was probably used because it is more general.

Did you like my suggestions?

In particular if

u*y1+y2=0

3u*t+|t|=0

u=-1/3 t<0

u=1/3 t>0

Hence

Linearly independent

- #5

cronxeh

Gold Member

- 961

- 10

W=det(3t abs(t); 3 abs(t)/t) =

3*t*abs(1,t)-3*abs(t) != 0

3*t*abs(1,t)-3*abs(t) != 0

- #6

- 319

- 0

lurflurf said:In particular if

u*y1+y2=0

3u*t+|t|=0

u=-1/3 t<0

u=1/3 t>0

Hence

Linearly independent

Can you tell me how that makes it linearly independent cuz I don't quite get it...

- #7

- 319

- 0

cronxeh said:W=det(3t abs(t); 3 abs(t)/t) =

3*t*abs(1,t)-3*abs(t) != 0

what does abs(1,t) mean? And can't you cancel out the t's when you do 3*t*|t|/t?

- #8

lurflurf

Homework Helper

- 2,440

- 138

Things are simpler since n=2physicsss said:Can you tell me how that makes it linearly independent cuz I don't quite get it...

we want to study

a y1+b y2=0

3at+b|t|=0

A nice way to see this is to concider (-infinity,0] and [0,infinity)

(-infinity,0]

3at+b|t|=0

3at-bt=0

(3a-b)t=0

(3a-b)=0

[0,infinity)

3at+b|t|=0

3at+bt=0

(3a+b)t=0

(3a+b)=0

so if this holds for the whole real line we have a system

3a-b=0

3a+b=0

This can only be true if a=b=0

Linearly independent

Another view if they were dependent

3at+b|t|=0

b is not zero (if it were a would need to be since t is not always 0)

(1/b)(3at+b|t|)=0

3(a/b)t+|t|=0

call a/b u and let it depend on t

3ut+|t|=0

solve for u

u=-sign(t)/3

u is clearly not constant so they must be linearly independent.

Also check out the above deal where an even function and an odd function must be linearly independent.

Share:

- Replies
- 11

- Views
- 7K