Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Logical error

  1. Mar 26, 2008 #1
    plz tell me where is the error here-
    1 = [tex]\sqrt{}1[/tex] = [tex]\sqrt{}(-1) (-1)[/tex] =[tex]\sqrt{}-1[/tex] [tex]\sqrt{}-1[/tex] = i[tex]^{}2[/tex] = -1

    so we get 1= -1. what is the error here?
  2. jcsd
  3. Mar 26, 2008 #2
    sorry look at this form. This is more understandable than the previous one
    1= [tex]\sqrt{1}[/tex] = [tex]\sqrt{(-1) (-1)}[/tex]= [tex]\sqrt{-1}[/tex][tex]\sqrt{-1}[/tex] = i i = i[tex]^{2}[/tex] = -1
  4. Mar 26, 2008 #3


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member
    Dearly Missed

    The error lies in the assumption that the square root operation when performed on negative (or in general complex) numbers follow exactly those laws valid when you restrict square rooting to positive numbers.

    It just doesn't.
  5. Mar 26, 2008 #4
    Did you want to say that we can't apply the laws for square-rooting of positive no. to this situation? Plz explain details. What is the exact logic to give in this situation?
  6. Mar 26, 2008 #5


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    [tex]\sqrt{ab}=\sqrt a\sqrt b[/tex] is only valid for [itex]a,b\ge0[/itex].
  7. Mar 26, 2008 #6
    Again it raises another question.
    On the basis of which statement you can say the following statement is valid-

  8. Mar 27, 2008 #7
    It's valid for a,b>=0 because there is a valid proof of it. this proof doesn't work if a or b can be negative. this proof uses as a definition of the square root that x is the square root of y, if x is positive and x*x = y. in that case there can be only one such number

    1. :[tex](\sqrt{ab})^2 = ab[/tex] by the definition of square root
    2. : [tex](\sqrt{a})^2 = a[/tex] by the definition of square root
    3. : [tex](\sqrt{b})^2 = b[/tex] by the definition of square root
    4. : [tex](\sqrt{ab})^2 = (\sqrt{a})^2 (\sqrt{b})^2 [/tex]
    5. : [tex](\sqrt{ab})^2 = (\sqrt{a}\sqrt{b})^2 [/tex] associativity
    6. : [tex]\sqrt{ab} = \sqrt{a}\sqrt{b} [/tex] definition of square root

    the last step only works if [tex]\sqrt{ab}[/tex] and [tex]\sqrt{a}\sqrt{b}[/tex] must be positive. if this was not the case [tex]\sqrt{ab} = -\sqrt{a}\sqrt{b} [/tex] could also be possible
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook