# Lorentz's force confusion

1. Apr 25, 2015

### cnh1995

If a charge is moving in a magnetic field with velocity v, q(vXB) force acts on it. If a current carrying conductor is placed in a magnetic field, it experiences a force BiLsinθ
(all symbols have usual meaning). But the reason behind the later force is the interaction between two magnetic fields;the one already existing and the one created by current. In my textbook, the derivation of this BiLsinθ force starts with Lorentz's force equation. How can we use that equation?? The cause of that force is not Lorentz force but the interaction of two fields.
Also,why isn't the Hall effect seen in this case?? Why is it limited to specific materials only?

2. Apr 25, 2015

### Delta²

No the reason of the Laplace force (BiLsinθ force) is not the interaction of two fields, it is the interaction of the one external field with the moving charged particles that make up the current i. A field cannot apply a force to another field, a field applies a force to a particle.

Ofcourse the particle that accepts the force can be generating a field of his own which field will interact with other particles and the source particle itself but thats another story.

Last edited: Apr 25, 2015