- #1
docnet
Gold Member
- 691
- 343
- TL;DR Summary
- How much physics do you need to understand how black holes are created?
Hello,
This is a question I've been pondering on my own for some time. I have no formal education in advanced physics, only at the introductory undergrad level.
I read that immense pressure can create black holes by compressing matter. I've read Laurence Krauss explain you'd need to compress Earth to the size of an apple. After approaching a certain density, the gravitational pull of the object on itself becomes great enough to overcome the electromagnetic repulsion between atoms. This makes sense because gravity has an inverse square relationship with distance. If an object is imploding, it will continue imploding until it has zero volume.
My question is do physicists explain how gravity becomes greater than the electromagnetic repulsion between atoms? Electromagnetic repulsion has the same relationship with distance, and the electromagnetic forces between atoms are much stronger than gravity at large distances. It seems like the repulsive forces should just get stronger with increasing density. Why does after a certain density does the EM force give?
Another wacky question: If we assume that atoms of different elements have varying strengths of electromagnetic repulsion, would a black hole created from titanium have a different density than a black hole created from an equal mass of helium?
This is a question I've been pondering on my own for some time. I have no formal education in advanced physics, only at the introductory undergrad level.
I read that immense pressure can create black holes by compressing matter. I've read Laurence Krauss explain you'd need to compress Earth to the size of an apple. After approaching a certain density, the gravitational pull of the object on itself becomes great enough to overcome the electromagnetic repulsion between atoms. This makes sense because gravity has an inverse square relationship with distance. If an object is imploding, it will continue imploding until it has zero volume.
My question is do physicists explain how gravity becomes greater than the electromagnetic repulsion between atoms? Electromagnetic repulsion has the same relationship with distance, and the electromagnetic forces between atoms are much stronger than gravity at large distances. It seems like the repulsive forces should just get stronger with increasing density. Why does after a certain density does the EM force give?
Another wacky question: If we assume that atoms of different elements have varying strengths of electromagnetic repulsion, would a black hole created from titanium have a different density than a black hole created from an equal mass of helium?