Measuring energy and its change

In summary: What is not relative, between different reference frames, is energy changes (differences). Energy differences are the conserved measures of physical changes. So we can measure the energy of a system or compare the energy of one system to the energy of another system but only energy differences have significance.
  • #1
fog37
1,549
107
Hello Forum,

I understand that energy, either kinetic is a relative quantity whose value depends on the frame of reference and its motion. Is that true for potential energy as well?

I read on a physics book that only changes in energy can be measure. What does that exactly mean? Why can we not measure energy directly but only its changes? Energy is apparently the measure of change of a system. What matters are energy differences and energy changes. Is it not correct to state that a system has a certain amount of energy at a particular time? Should we only talk about energy gains and energy losses for a system?

Thanks!
cleardot.gif
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Mechanical potential energy is also relative. Consider the gravitational potential energy of a book on a shelf. We arbitrarily assign one of the shelves as zero.

There are many forms of energy other than mechanical PE and KE. Electrical, chemical, heat, nuclear ...
 
  • #3
Thanks anorlunda.

I would say that all forms of energy can be derived from kinetic and potential. For example, temperature is microscopically tied to kinetic energy. Bonds in molecules to potential energy...

I am still not sure why we can only measure energy changes only and not the particular energy of a system...
 
  • #5
Thank you. Very interesting.

It still does not seem to address, unless I have missed it, why energy changes is all we can measure and worry about and why energy is a measure of the change in a system while force the agent of change...
 
  • #6
fog37 said:
Thank you. Very interesting.

It still does not seem to address, unless I have missed it, why energy changes is all we can measure and worry about and why energy is a measure of the change in a system while force the agent of change...

So, what would you say is the absolute energy of, say, the Solar System? Something that is not frame dependent.

You said:

fog37 said:
I would say that all forms of energy can be derived from kinetic and potential.

So, what are you going to do to establish an absolute kinetic energy of the Solar System?
 
  • Like
Likes fog37
  • #7
Thanks Perok. I am not sure about the absolute energy of the solar system. I would just say that its value is relative in virtue of these arguments:
  • Kinetic energy is relative (depends on the observer's state of motion)
  • Potential energy is relative (can always add an arbitrary constant value to it)
  • Work is relative since displacement is relative
What is not relative, between different reference frames, is energy changes (differences). Energy differences are the conserved measures of physical changes. So we can measure the energy of a system or compare the energy of one system to the energy of another system but only energy differences have significance.

How do we compare a system with energy ##E_1## and another system with energy ##E_2 <E_1##? The scalar value of their energies is not important. System with energy ##E_1## has a higher ability to change its own dynamical state and/or configuration state OR also a higher ability to change the dynamical state and/or the configuration state of another system...I feel like all myriad forms of energy are somewhat a form of KE or PE. For example, thermal energy is microscopic PE+KE of the object's constituents. Nuclear energy is some form of potential energy deriving from fusion or fission of the nuclei.

The equation ##E=mc^2## from special relativity then states that mass and energy are intrinsically related. So a hotter object, with more thermal energy, has a higher mass than a cooler object...
 

1. How is energy measured?

Energy is measured in joules (J), which is the standard unit of measurement for energy. Other commonly used units include calories (cal) and kilowatt-hours (kWh).

2. What is the difference between potential and kinetic energy?

Potential energy is the energy an object has due to its position or state, while kinetic energy is the energy an object has due to its motion. Potential energy can be converted into kinetic energy and vice versa.

3. How is the change in energy calculated?

The change in energy is calculated by subtracting the initial energy from the final energy. This can be represented by the equation ∆E = Ef - Ei, where ∆E is the change in energy, Ef is the final energy, and Ei is the initial energy.

4. What factors affect the measurement of energy?

The measurement of energy can be affected by various factors such as the type and state of the object, the distance and direction of motion, and external forces acting on the object.

5. How is energy conservation demonstrated through measurements?

Energy conservation is demonstrated through measurements by showing that the total amount of energy in a closed system remains constant. This can be done by measuring the initial and final energy states and showing that the difference is equal to zero.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
27
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
393
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
54
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
15
Views
300
Back
Top