Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Mistakes about illuminance

  1. Sep 11, 2011 #1

    a b

    User Avatar

    Hello everybody,
    this question is about an exercise but I post it here because it is not homework, it is an exercise that I've done to learn by myself. I hope it is ok.
    It is an exercise from Irodov book (exercise 5.12)
    The exercise says:
    A small spherical lamp, uniformly luminous with radius R= 6.0 cm is suspended at an height h of 3 metres above the floor;
    The luminance of the lamp is L=2.0*10^4 cd/m2, indipendent of direction.
    Find the illuminance of the floor directly below the lamp.

    the solution that the book (and my teacher) gives is

    [tex]I= \pi\frac{R^{2}}{h^{2}} L = 25.13\, \, lux [/tex]

    I tried to solve it in this way:
    the simmetry of the problem gives us many advantages; we can obtain the total luminous flux of the lamp by multiplying the luminance by the total surface and by 2 pi steradians (half of the maximum solid angle, because i assume the sphere doesn't radiate inside itself)

    [tex]F=L (2 \pi) (4 \pi R^{2} )= L (8 \pi^{^2} R^{2} )[/tex]

    then, to have the illuminance of the floor just below the lamp, we can divide the total flux by the area of the sphere having radius h:

    [tex]I= L (8 \pi^{^2} R^{2} )/ (4 \pi h^{2})= 2 \pi L \frac{R^{2}}{h^2}=50.27\; lux[/tex]

    but as you can see it is exactly twice the solution given by the book.
    I suppose i am wrong, but i cannot understand why. can you help please?
    Thank you in advance, sorry for my english
  2. jcsd
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Can you offer guidance or do you also need help?