Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

MOVIE: What the #$*!(bleep) do we know

  1. Sep 10, 2004 #1
    MOVIE: "What the #$*!(bleep) do we know"

    Have any of you had the chance to see this film yet? Apparently it is a documentry concerning modern physics, neuroscience, and mysticism. Seems like it might be a really interesting one to get others interested in our ecletic endevours. Here is the home page:

    http://www.whatthebleep.com/home.php [Broken]

    Apparently this started in Oregon and has been spreading via word of mouth and is making quite a splash! This one should be interesting! I just hope that Depok Chopra does not try to cash-in on this one with his quantum of consciousness, I really dont think he can spare it!
    Last edited by a moderator: May 1, 2017
  2. jcsd
  3. Sep 11, 2004 #2


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    I think you should emphasize the mysticism part and downplay the science part. I looked at the list of "experts" interviewed for the neuroscience part. First, they are all physicians, not researchers, oh, except for the one chiropractor who apparently dabbles in neuroscience on the side. :eek: It still might be entertaining, but I wouldn't expect them to live up to their claims that it's real, not science fiction. From their cast of so-called experts, I'd say it will have a very healthy dose of fiction. On the other hand, if we all get to see it, maybe we can have a really fun time in the debunking topic. :biggrin:
  4. Sep 11, 2004 #3
    I just hope Deepok Chopra doesnt show up with his "quantum" of conciousness!

    Yeah it does seem like they are pushing for more of a modern mystcism angle which is code for book sales and vacation retreats for the gullable. :confused: I think I have seen a book or two from Fred Wolf, one the featured physicists, and he seems to be of the "Tao of physics" genre.
    Either way it looks like it will be entertaining as well hopefully will give some more people a perspective on modern physics and some of the philisophical implications. Until they actual do the math, they will be bogged down in ambiguous concepts that will always evade their comprehension. Of course that is the driving "market" force for many book sales like "Tao of Physics". Perhaps they may elighten the public a bit. I can only Hope!
  5. Oct 4, 2004 #4
    undisputed facts re: the film makers and the film...Propaganda??

    1. In addition to the films three directors, there were actors and others involved in the production who are long time "students" of Ramthas' School of enlightenment.

    2. A disproportionate amount of time was given in voice and film to Ramtha, Dr. Joe dispenza, and Miceal Ledwith.

    3. Dr Joe Dispenza and Miceal Ledwith are both long time students and "appointed teachers at Ramthas' school of enlightenment (RSE)

    4. Dr Joe Dispenza (the one who creates his day) has gone to court and testified that his teacher (ramtha) has told him that terrible times are coming and that he needs to protect his family. He also invested over $10,000.00 in an infamous scam that infected RSE and was touted by Ramtha as a vehicle to gain fabulous wealth and many of the schools membership lost substantial sums of money. Some lost their entire life savings.
    This is the person who teaches the brain science in RSE.

    5.Miceal Ledwith a clergyman with a rather dubious past (see http://unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=36&si=770458&issue_id=7565 [Broken]) is the one chosen by the film makers to be the theological spokesman. He is also the theologian in residence of RSE.
    He also has been marketing several products within the school and its followers. Guess that could not have been done to easily in the Catholic church.

    6. The following persons in the film have all spoken at RSE and sold books there.

    Fred Allen Wolf
    Dr Candice Pert
    Amit Gotswami
    John Haglin
    Joe Dispenza
    Miceal Ledwith
    and of course the big guy himself, Ramtha

    7. One of the scientists who was in the film and had never appeared at the school is Dr David Albert Professor and Director of Philosophical Physics at Columbia university.
    He has stated in several venues that his views were totally misrepresented in the film. He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community.
    He even called in to a radio program the director was on to discuss this and was cut off. The host of the show said this was done because it was "negative"
    so much for no good or bad, that is unless it is convienent.

    8. To date, there has been no response as to where the information which lead to the story about the indians not being able to see the ships of Columbus originated from. There appears to be no evidence to support this claim. In addition, the film mentioned "clipper ships" which were not even in existence at that time. Perhaps that is why they couldn't see them.

    There were many more, but I will leave them for others. If anyone has any information to refute any of the facts laid out here, I will be more then willing to retract them.

    They are relevant because of the deliberateness on the part of the film makers to keep certain facts unknown (ironically, it is I making the unknown know) and misrepresent others.
    Last edited by a moderator: May 1, 2017
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook