Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Musical Theory

  1. Mar 29, 2007 #1
    I am not sure where this is exactly suppose to go but I need some help with the mathematics behind musical theory. I searched the forums and didnt really find a related topic. The instraments I play are guitar and piano. I recently started the piano though and it made me question many things about music. One of my biggest problems occurs with the E to Fhalf step and the B to C..
  2. jcsd
  3. Mar 29, 2007 #2
    This is not my only problem.. If someone could move this thread to the proper location or elaborate on this I could continue with my questions. Please dont copy and paste things you've found in wikipedia. I need a couple of funsters that actually know what they are talking about. Thank you x)
  4. Mar 29, 2007 #3
    No one has an idea about this or can not direct me to the right forum/member?
  5. Mar 29, 2007 #4


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Patience is a virtue. :tongue:

    That said, you don't really seem to have asked anything -- I have no idea what you want to know!
  6. Mar 29, 2007 #5
    I guess what I need to know is how many sharps and flats are in the most common songs you see (scales related to each tonic) and after this is established, maybe a formula trying to connect the transpositions/modes.
  7. Mar 29, 2007 #6
    I understand that all music is made up of patterns but if someone could show me an example of the patterns relating to a certain mode in a modern song (or example), then we could establish some kind of formula so it would be easier for me, and if there are any aspiring muiscians on this forum, to apply to any key that you may come upon. The reason why it would be nice to just mention popular examples is because it would be easier to apply it to something that most are capable of playing.
  8. Mar 29, 2007 #7

    matt grime

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    One can write down, say, arithmetic progressions, and derive scales from them if one felt so inclined. There are many studies on this. Just google them if no one wants to, or no one is able to, explain them here.

    Even now you really haven't asked a question (but that is I suspect because you don't know how to form the question you want to ask).

    I would suggest there are many, infinitely many, patterns one could use to write scales with, though they will not all be pleasant to your ear. They may of course be pleasant to someone else's. The fact that the intervals, in semitones, for a major scale, go


    *is* a pattern. So I don't see what you're asking there.
  9. Mar 29, 2007 #8
    That is Ionian.. I guess since no one understands my previous posts - could someone explain to me their take on music. Its not a question really but rather a request for someone to share with me their idea of how to play music or how they structure the songs/patterns.
  10. Mar 29, 2007 #9
    One thing that might be interesting to you is the Schillinger System, Schillinger tried to make a theory of melody, harmony and rhythm.

    As a hobby, I have a particular interest in modulations on scales with exact intonations. An area that is currently underdeveloped in music composition.
  11. Mar 29, 2007 #10


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper
    Education Advisor
    Gold Member

    Are you trying to request a knowledge discussion about acoustics, or wavelengths & frequencies, or musical notation, or something else related to music?
  12. Mar 29, 2007 #11
    i think the answer he's looking for depends on the scale, in the 12 note western music scale the center key is C major, from C its 2,2,1,2,2,2,1. every 2 is a whole step, 1 is a half. funny that you'd know a classical mode and not that?

    how would i structure a song?, find something that sounds nice to my ears and build on it from there, i have met people who can pull out the key, progression, time and make the song or build a new one based on what mood their looking for.
    Last edited: Mar 29, 2007
  13. Mar 29, 2007 #12

    matt grime

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    Almost surely not with mathematics. There are certaily some pleasant things written purely abstractly and mathematically, but not many. Perhaps some people have analysed compositions and found some patterns, and certainly some people have discovered some scales using purely mathematical means (like I said you can easily google that). But whether you think it is *good* or not is entirely a cultural phenomenon.


    is the first thing that a google for 'music mathematical patterns' returned.

    http://www.math.niu.edu/~rusin/uses-math/music/ [Broken]

    is a whole lot better.

    Sure, you didnt' want a wiki-scrape, but since you're asking for opinions, there are some for you. Perhaps some people here would be good enough to read and discuss it with you.
    Last edited by a moderator: May 2, 2017
  14. Mar 30, 2007 #13
    From my understanding - a basic major scale has that pattern of whole whole half whole whole whole half and I was to believe that was ionian. No? The reason why Cmajor is easy because it has no sharps or flats. But something useful like saying that most rock and roll music is derived from "House of the Rising Sun", the pattern and chords. If you gave examples of scales from popular songs and explain them it would be alot easier for us to get on the same level.
  15. Mar 30, 2007 #14


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    What key signature is "easiest" depends heavily on what instrument you're playing and what you're playing. e.g. when playing oboe, I would find G major or D major easier than C major.

    And unless you have perfect pitch, just by listening you cannot tell the difference between a band playing a song in C major, or playing that same song in Cb major. (Unless you knew some very specific details about the instruments -- e.g. you notice a violin playing on an open string)
  16. Mar 30, 2007 #15

    matt grime

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    These days you can't hear the differences. But you used to be able to, until that damn piano came along. Until then, a C sharp and a D flat were different notes.

    But the house of the rising sun is still played in a scale, and a well known one , though not to me. It is probably a very old pentatonic scale, and nothing interesting.

    Anyway, the idea that C maj is easy 'cos there are no sharps or flats is meaningless, and entirely dependent on you thinking a piano is *the* only instrument, and current notation as *the* only notation possible. There would be no sharps or flats in G maj, or G min, if we just redefined our notation.

    Go and look at, say, tablature, for guitars (based on old lute music) to realise the cultural dependency for this (unfounded) preference for C maj.
    Last edited: Mar 30, 2007
  17. Mar 30, 2007 #16
    ah hemm, start with c major and count up 5. c d e f g A now transpose that c major pattern starting with A, guess what you have the scale of A major, repeat for the next key, math is everywhere in music.
  18. Apr 2, 2007 #17
    I believe working with guitar tabulature is the easiest because you dont need to know how read music to do the math.

    To say we are starting on D and we applied the major patter. D E F# G A B C# - This D Major, right? Lets analyze House of the Rising Sun. The way I learned to play the song is in G major but I am not sure if thats right. Who would like to start with House of the Rising Sun?
  19. Apr 2, 2007 #18
    go out and get a music theory book, you might not feel it right away but you'll be kicking yourself when you try to advance in your lessons. tab is good as an !accompaniment! to notation for guitar.
  20. Apr 3, 2007 #19
    This is hopeless.. If anyone ever scrolls by this in the future please private message me your idea about this. I know I will probably still be stuck on this.
    thank youoxoxox
  21. Aug 13, 2007 #20
    helo you are only discusing about music theory. Music theory provides diferent way of understanding and apreciating music. you probably can't get far in making good music til the next century with only mathematics. you need to understand why somnething sounds good there's are many theories besides . there are also redundancies.for eg. you can name chords in many ways but a particular scale or mode helps you to decide why to name it like that. this is a very vast subject the best advice is to get theory books. there are books on arranging and everything you can think of in music.
    Its all about harmony,counterpoint,voice leading etc
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook