Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

News My RunIN with the JackBooted Thugs

  1. Mar 9, 2005 #1
    went to JAIL monday for calling 911 after a JACKBOOTED THUG PULL A GUN ON ME

    I was trying to unload my car at the dock to row out to my boat
    as I pulled in to the front of the dock I saw an unmarked white van parked there
    so I parked behind it and got out to unload my stuff on the dock

    I then noticed these THUGS had handcuffed a local man and the two coasties had NO ID
    just a printed T-shirt and blue pants and GUN BELTS as part of a NEW homeland force
    that has been VERY FACIST in actions localy so I began to speak to them ABOUT THAT
    as I was begining to get my stuff out of the car
    I picked up an OAR to place it on the dock
    I was about 20 feet away from him and DIDNOT MAKE ANY ATTEMPT to HIT OR THREATEN HIM
    I was just caring the OAR at wast level by my side
    so I droped the oar and was ordered to leave the dock where my small boat was docked
    at this point I thought I WAS THE ONE ASSALTED

    so I got in my car and drove to park the car away from the armed men
    thinking about this BS and the THUG with a GUN threating ME and preventing my useing the dock
    I desided to call 911 and report HIS ACTIONS that I thought was an ASSALT on ME
    so I went to a payphone and spoke to the local cops dispacher
    they said they would send an officer
    so I waited and watched from about a 100 yards away
    in a few minites two local cops showed up and spoke to the coasties
    after a while
    the the coasties got in their van and drove it away from where they had been parked
    sence no cop had came to were I was and I thought the coasties had left
    I walked over near the dock but stoped before reaching it and spoke from a distance of about 50 ft to the local cops saying I had called 911
    the local cops instructed me to approch them and show ID so I did
    then I noticed the coasties were still there , they just moved and reparked their van
    I was told to wait a minite

    after some discusion with the coasties the local cops ARRESTED ME
    for Agg Assault on a law inforcesment officer and interfearing with justice
    they said because I had RETURNED TO THE DOCK
    BUT I only did that because the local cops told me to!!!!!
    then they searched my car and took the oar and took me to jail under a 17,000 bond to get out
    so I had to wait over night to see a Judge the next day
    the judge said a oar was NOT a WEAPON so reduced the charge to simple assalt and the bond to 4000 so I paid my ransom and got out
    remember no one was hit swong at or threaten EXCPT ME BY THE THUG by A GUN DRAWN AND POINTED AT ME for no good reason

    the arrest was a result of my calling 911 to report a thug with a gun
    and my attempt to speak with the local cops about it after I thought the coastie who pulled the GUN had left the site
    and offical retalliations for dareing to question their illegal actions
    Last edited: Mar 9, 2005
  2. jcsd
  3. Mar 9, 2005 #2


    User Avatar

    Staff: Mentor

    After reading your story, I'd say you were wrong and they were right.

    This was the coastguard?
    I hope you realize how dumb that was. You come across as a hot head that failed to excersize common sense. You did interfere with an arrest in progress.

    Although they were definitely within their rights to have you arrested, the charge seems a bit extreme, but I have a feeling from your post that you were being beligerant. You brought it on yourself. You do realize that you are also guilty of misusing 911 and that alone can get you arrested.

    I hope that you learn how to control your temper if you have to go to court.
  4. Mar 9, 2005 #3
    I only reported the facts
    a man claiming to be a coastie in a T-shirt pulled a GUN and POINTED IT At ME
    to the 911 people

    yours is part of a VERY DANGERIOUS MIND SET that the PIGS DO NO WRONG


    reread that and think about it
  5. Mar 9, 2005 #4


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    I'm tellin' ya. Come to Canada.

    We believe that 'free nation' still means something.
  6. Mar 9, 2005 #5


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    ray b, if you saw them in the midst of an arrest, but saw nothing of what happened prior to that, how do you think your interference was anything but interference? If you were concerned they were not really coast guard (I'm assuming that's what you mean by "coasties") by their uniforms, standing around asking them questions and getting in the way was not the appropriate action anyway. Had you simply called 911 for that reason, just to get some uniformed police out to confirm this was a legitimate arrest, or if you witnessed someone beating the person in handcuffs, something that drastic, and then stayed out of the way, that would have seemed reasonable. However, to have started asking questions when they needed to be focusing on the person in custody is dangerously distracting to them as well as you. You saw they had someone in custody and clearly by talking to them, in whatever tone you may have taken (your tone here doesn't suggest you were likely showing much respect for them), would have been aware they were in the process of making an arrest, and they knew that. Because you continued to approach in their direction with an oar after this, they have no way to know if you intended to use it or not if you were getting in their face about making an arrest. It is safer for them to stop you and have you drop it and walk away before you get close enough to be a threat to them.

    You also could have reported their actions after the fact. It did not require calling 911 from what you described. The fact that you refer to them as "pigs" already tells me your lack of respect for those in uniform.

    From what you have shared here, I agree with Evo, there were probably multiple reasons they could have arrested you, so you may have gotten off easy they didn't charge you with ALL of them.
  7. Mar 9, 2005 #6


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Get a grip, man. You had no idea what the coast guard men were actually doing! What if the man they had in handcuffs was stealing, vandalizing, or killing people? What if he was trying to steal your boat? You had no idea what was actually happening, yet you immediately sided against the coast guard, then attempted to get in their way.

    Even if you think the coast guard generally abuses their authority, walking into an arrest situation (which is already necessarily tense) of which you know nothing about is a very bad idea, simply because you know nothing about it.

    And no, I do not generally side with "pigs." Yes, I generally think law enforcement does routinely abuse authority. However, the appropriate way to voice such concerns is not to walk into the middle of a arrest and cause them additional stress! The police are human, too, and I totally respect every single method they use to ensure their own personal safety. The coast guard men had no idea who you were, what kind of weapons you might or might not have been carrying, or what your intent was. It's entirely possible that you were a partner with the man they already had handcuffed, and your intention was to walk up and shoot them both in the face. Since they cannot know what your real intention was in walking into the scene, they must assume the worst for the sake of their own well-being.

    Besides, this is not a big deal! Some man got handcuffed! Not beaten to the ground, not held in a chokehold, not shot needlessly -- just handcuffed! Handcuffing is usually not an act of offense, it's an act of defense, and I have no problem with policemen defending themselves.

    The proper way to sort this kind of thing out is at the police station, or the courtroom -- not in the heat of passion in the middle of an arrest. Your actions were absolutely out-of-line, and I'm happy to hear they dealt with you appropriately.

    - Warren
  8. Mar 9, 2005 #7
    the man had a small bag of suger in his pocket for his bosses coffee on the job
    this is the typical harrassment type BS the coasties are up to currently
    searching ordinary locals going about there private biz not once but over and over for the last few months

    they are too chicken to go to bad parts of the area or look for the real crimes
    so they just sit in the dock parking lot board to death bothering everyone who doesnot look rich because they can and no-one will standup to them :yuck:
    we are tired of them and their BS
  9. Mar 9, 2005 #8


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Then call your mayor, or the coast guard, and speak to someone with some power to actually change the way the coast guard is operating around your dock. Taking things "into your own hands" by trying to harrass them is, as you've already discovered, a bad idea. There are better ways to handle things.

    If you have information about real crimes being committed (not just "oh yeah, down that-a-way there are some REAL shady types), tell them. Work with them, and they will not only serve your area better, but they'll treat everyone there better, too. If you see them often, befriend them; they're people too. Learn their names and say hello to them. As crazy as it sounds, you might even consider offering them a cup of coffee and explaining your grief to them, in proper, calm language.

    - Warren
  10. Mar 9, 2005 #9


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Gold Member

    You really shouldn't have called 911, either. 911 is set up specifically for emergencies and you were not in the midst of an emergency. From the info you have given, neither you nor the man being handcuffed was in any danger. There are proper ways to file grievances and clogging up an emergency line so that real people in real danger cannot get through is not the way do to it.

    By the way, why are all of your posts truncated at the ends of the lines like that? No line ever goes all the way to the right side of the text box. The same thing happens to Tournesol. What causes that?
  11. Mar 9, 2005 #10


    User Avatar

    Staff: Mentor

    So, chalk that up to lessons learned:

    1. Don't call 911 unless you are in the middle of a real emergency.
    2. Don't interfere with police (military or otherwise) business.
    3. Police (military or otherwise) don't have to be in a police uniform to be on duty and making an arrest.
    4. Learn to let things go. If you had just let it go(several things), you wouldn't have gone to jail.
    5. (related to 4) Don't be confrontational. Be utterly respectful - subservient, even. And that does not just apply to police or other authority figures.
    Last edited: Mar 9, 2005
  12. Mar 9, 2005 #11
    or be a good GERMAN the party knows best
    well we saw how that went down

    the price of freedom is high
    only those who fight for it deserve to keep it
  13. Mar 9, 2005 #12


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Understanding the appropriate place to voice one's concern over law enforcement does not make one a German, a nazi, a fascist, or even a conservative.

    As I have already said, I agree with you that police often abuse their authority, and I don't condone it at all. I'm probably as liberal as they come on the topic, in fact. (Don't get me started on the California Highway Patrol.) On the other hand, I am capable of understanding that policemen are also human beings, and have a right to protect themselves. Their work is dangerous, and most of their apparently-offensive actions are really wholly defensive.

    You presented yourself to them as a threat, and they treated you, necessarily, as a threat. Good for them.

    - Warren
  14. Mar 9, 2005 #13


    User Avatar

    Staff: Mentor

    How can I possibly let this go? :yuck:
  15. Mar 9, 2005 #14


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Have you not noticed my dry wit yet?!

    - Warren
  16. Mar 9, 2005 #15


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    LOL! Just when you think you know who your friends are.
  17. Mar 10, 2005 #16
    i woudl normally be very sympathetic to your cause. However, the over usage of 'Jackbooted' and 'thugs', instead of simply explaining the facts, makes me believe there's
    1>more to this story
    2>bias in your version
  18. Mar 10, 2005 #17
    well if they correctly identified themselves as coast guard and you didn't turn around and leave then and there, they were within thier legal right to arrest you, and you should have heeded thier warning. If they didn't correctly identify themselves then they broke the law. It's that simple, case closed.

    You can talk about abuse of power or conspiracy if you want, but from a legal standpoint, it sounds like you are the guilty party.
  19. Mar 10, 2005 #18


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    I have a few more things to point out as I've read the accounting over again. ray b begins by saying they were coast guard but had no ID. So long as they had identified themselves to the person they were arresting, there is no reason they need to display their ID to anyone else. How would you know they have no ID on them? Does this mean while they were in the middle of their arrest, you were asking them to show you ID? That's certainly interferring.

    You then seem to be claiming you had some doubts about them being Coast Guard because they were wearing a uniform consisting of a t-shirt, yet, you did seem to know they were Coast Guard, and you claim you've seen them in the area before, so you do know they patrol that area. And, if you are out on a boat often, and in the area often, you would know that the Coast Guard does wear t-shirts as part of their uniform, not at all unlike cops who patrol on bicycles also often wear t-shirts with the printed logo rather than a uniform less suited for their activities. In other words, you contradict your own statement.

    Then, in your later reply, you state that the person being arrested was arrested for having a bag of sugar in his pocket. Now, how is it that you learned this if you knew nothing of what was going on? Perhaps it was, perhaps he was wrongly arrested because they thought that sugar was an illegal drug, in which case, he has his own recourse to file a complaint, and if you had stood back and not interferred, you could have made a credible witness to his treatment during the arrest if he needed that. However, if that's just what that guy told you, do you really know that's what he was arrested for? Perhaps he's claiming that, but that bag did contain illegal substances, or maybe the bag had nothing to do with the arrest at all, and was just bagged as added evidence when they searched his pockets during the arrest and weren't sure what it was. Regardless, at the time of the arrest, you had no way of knowing.

    As was pointed out, it very well could have been YOUR boat he had been caught trying to steal.

    If you thought there was a problem, nobody is saying you needed to keep it to yourself, we're saying there are proper channels to follow to file a formal complaint and have them investigated. Calling 911 is not part of those proper channels.

    I do have to address the whole "cops are pigs" attitude here though. I have relatives who are cops, and that means at family gatherings, I run into their other friends who are cops as well. I will vouch for them that they are real people with tough jobs. Yes, there are cops who abuse their authority, or are just plain bad cops, but it's not as bad as what the nightly news will lead you to believe. For the most part, they have very good hearts and go into it genuinely wanting to help protect the public and get the bad guys off the streets. However, in that line of work, they see a LOT of horrible things, and spend every day exposed to the worst side of human nature. It is stressful and a real struggle for them to not let this jade their view of all people. Divorce rates are high among them, mostly because they just close up within themselves at home...they don't do a job you can talk about around the dinner table with the wife and kids. Some do snap under the pressure.

    Anything you can do to make them more assured you are not a threat to them can go a long way if they don't know who you are. They are used to be confronted by people all the time, have come to expect it and react to it. They are braced to have knives or guns pulled on them, or any other weapon. They have families they want to go home to and that they need to provide for, and don't want to risk being killed by some hothead. When you realize they are people, just like anyone else, and have a tough job to do, and get a lot of criticism for it, even when they're doing a good job at it, it makes it easier to see things through their eyes.

    People get curious when the see someone being arrested, but stand back, don't distract them from their job, don't suddenly reach into your pocket or glove compartment for something, do what you can to let them do their job without worrying you might be a threat too. Remember, adrenaline may still be running high for them, making them even a little more twitchy, if it was a difficult arrest or weapons were involved.

    These are good things to keep in mind even for something as routine as a traffic stop. Do you know that just a smile and "hello sir" can go a long way toward softening their attitude and reminding them that there are people in the world who don't hate them for their job? Taking extra steps, like flicking on the interior light of the car if it's night so they can clearly see you helps to assure them you aren't up to anything either. Getting defensive only suggests to them you have something to be defensive about, right or wrong.

    But, hey, you'll have your day in court.
  20. Mar 10, 2005 #19

    They may not have been able to idenitfiy themselves as Coast Guard. Mainly for the fact that they may have been working under cover and identifing themselves could have put them in more danger then they were already in.

    Ray, you did interfere with the arrest they were trying to make. They were within their rights of pulling a gun on you because how would they know you weren't packing? I mean come on.

    If you were so upset that they had pulled a gun on you, why didn't you call the local police instead of 911. Moonbear (or Evo, I don't remember who...sorry :redface: ) is right in saying you misused the 911 line. You weren't in dire need for medical attention or police assistance. You should have stepped back and assessed the situation more carefully.

    By the way, Russ and Warren supporting the actions taken by the police doesn't make them Nazis. Nor does it mean that they hate you because you're Jewish. Its a moot and irelevent point in the conversation. I'm agree with Russ and Warren, the police were totally within their rights to arrest you and charge you with assault. I'm glad they dealt with you accordingly. You don't have to hit someone to be charged with assault.

    Read the definition of assault. Its the second definition. This might clear up any confusion of why they arrested you. Or at least part of it.

  21. Mar 10, 2005 #20
    Police officers and military personel do this job because no one else will. They work to ensure your safety and the safety of the general public. They are good people who have a tough job, but they do it out of love and service to protect you. It is very unfortunate that they see half the things they see. People in this line of work have families just like you or I do. They also have one of the most dangerous occupations around. They say good-bye to their families to leave for work in the morning and I can assure you, maybe once in a while or over the course of the day, their spouse wonders if they'll come home. It takes a strong and brave person to do what they do.

    Now I'm not saying there aren't bad police officers, because there are. It happens, their human. Just like you. All you can do as a citizen is be aware of your rights and how to exercise them within the confines of the law.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook