- #1
yihg500k7
- 3
- 1
Who can help me? My paper was submitted to Physical Review Letters in October 25, 2018. But the paper first rejected by Associate Editor of PRL in October 30, 2018, and he gave me a few comments on my manuscript. But I found that his comments were incorrect, so I resubmitted my manuscript to PRL in November 10, 2018 and responded to his comments. I find that my manuscript status has always been "With editors" from Monday to Thursday(From November 12, 2018 to November 15, 2018), and the manuscript submission system has this record: Ed. decision and / or Ref. comments to author; response rcvd, but Friday(November 16, 2018) my manuscript status was " Not under active consideration", and the record also disappeared in the manuscript submission system, and I did not receive any decision notification email from the editor.I contacted the Associate Editor of PRL, but the Associate Editor didn't give me any response. It is certain that the record are deleted by the Associate Editor. Because my response to his comments contained these words:”You make these comments only based on your own subjective assumptions without any evidence, the comments are unconvincing. So your comments are not valid.” He may not be happy to read these words. But these are facts.The Associate Editor has broken the rules. Please kindly tell me what I should do now.Thank you.