# Need help with something very odd.

Ok, we are given the known equation that momentum = mass times velocity.

p=mv.

What is dp/dr physically representing?

Given:

r = position.

dr/dt = v.

so

p = mdr/dt.

dp/dr = m/dt ? If so, that remains constant (or zero?) correct?

Homework Helper
Okay, momentum equals mass times velocity.
(That's basically the definition of momentum rather than a "known equation".)

p= mv.

IF m is a constant then dp/dt= m dv/dt= m a (mass times acceleration).

If m is not a constant (a very important consideration) then
dp/dt= m dv/dt+ dm/dt v.

dp/dt is, of course, "force"- that's basically, the definition of force.

dp/dr= (dp/dt)(dt/dr) (chain rule) or

dp/dr= (dp/dt)/(dr/dt)= (1/v)*force

Assuming constant mass, dp/dr= (m a)/v

I don't know that that "physically represents" anything in particular. I'm pretty sure it doesn't have a specific name.

As far as "dp/dr = m/dt" is concerned, that makes no sense at all- you have an "unattached" dt on the right.

That's what I am all confused about. Whether it represents anything at all, or if it will be a constant. A better way to visualize this is to imagine the mass is in an orbit.

Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
dp/dt= m dv/dt+ dm/dt v.

This is the force law for a rocket. The force dp/dt has rwo components, current mass times acceleration (m dv/dt) and rate of change of mass times current speed (v dm/dt). This latter is due to the exhaust; dm/dt is the rate that reaction mass is being shot out the back. Note that the higher v is, the more that a given dm/dt contributes to the force on the rocket.

Yes, that much I knew. But this is the question:

p =mv.

dp/dt =mdv/dt (m is constant in this case)

dp = mdv

dp/dr = mdv/dr

Now, dv = dr/dt so we get 1/dt

dp/dr = m/dt.

I am just interested in this. The change in momentum with respect to distance, or mass with respect to time. In an orbit (notice this condition) would this quantity whatever it is, be constant, or zero?

Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
You can't just divide out the dr's. derivatives like dr/dt aren't quotients exactly, they are the limits of quotients. It's allowable to multiply through, such as dr/dt = K, yields dr = Kdt ready for integration, but dividing out doesn't make sense.

Alright then.

dp = mdv

What does

dp/dr = mdv/dr represent?

You said dv=dr/dt. That is quite wrong. v=dr/dt (as you said in a previous post). Therefore, dv=d(dr/dt)=d^2r/dt. So you are misunderstanding the math.

You are using v=dr/dt. This is only true for 1-dimensional motion, for example, a mass moving along a straight line. In that case, what Hallsofivy said is right. dp/dr=F/v; in words, dp/dr is the ratio of force applied, to the velocity attained. It's not zero and not constant. For example, if the force is pushing the mass in the direction opposite to its motion, the mass will slow down, stop, and reverse. At the point at which it has stopped, v=0 so dp/dr=F/v is infinite.