One equals minus one?

  1. Apr 26, 2010 #1
    I think that I have proof of 1 being -1 and I can't find any flaw in it.
    Could you please take a look?

    -1=i² =>
    (-1)²=(i²)² =>
    1 = i^4 => take the square root both sides
    1 = i²

    i² = -1 v i² = 1

    Thus proving
    1 = -1
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 26, 2010
  2. jcsd
  3. Apr 26, 2010 #2


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    To confuse you a little more can you find the mistake: [itex]2=\sqrt{4}=\sqrt{(-2)^2}=-2[/itex].
  4. Apr 26, 2010 #3
    Yea I know those too xD
    Does that mean that it is correct? (but just not used since it's crazy)

    Edit: the √(-2)² is not -2, but 2 btw :P
    You probably meant (-2)² = √4 = 2²
    Last edited: Apr 26, 2010
  5. Apr 26, 2010 #4


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    No I meant exactly what I wrote, the root cancelling the square. We can't do this because we have defined taking the square root of a real number to be a positive value. This is called the principal square root. For the complex numbers this principal root is defined as [itex]\sqrt{z}=\sqrt{|z|}e^{i \pi/2}[/itex]. In general for complex numbers it is not even true that [itex]\sqrt{zw}=\sqrt{z}\sqrt{w}[/itex].
  6. Apr 26, 2010 #5
    [tex]a^{bc}=\left(a^b\right)^c[/tex] is not generally true. For example [tex]\left(\left(-1\right)^2\right)^{\frac 1 2}\neq-1[/tex]. You should be careful with this rule when the base is not a positive real number and the exponent is not an integer.
  7. Apr 26, 2010 #6
    I really don't get that o_O
    Could you dumb it down a little? (I'm a collage student)
  8. Apr 26, 2010 #7


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    We can write every complex number z in the form [tex]z=|z|e^{i \theta}[/tex] with |z| the distance between z and the origin and [itex]\theta[/itex] the angle between the x-axis and |z| (polar coordinates). If you have had some complex numbers you should know this representation of a complex number. From this it follows that [itex]i=e^{i \pi/2}[/itex] and [itex]i^4=e^{2 \pi i}[/itex]. Now taking the square root of i^4 we get [tex]\sqrt{i^4}=e^{i \pi}=-1[/tex].
  9. Apr 26, 2010 #8
    No that's not what it means, all of our mathematical foundations would be bogus if we ever said "it's true, but it's too crazy.. so it's pretty much false".
    Sqrt(x) is a function (input/output relationships are unique), so given a number (perhaps 9), Sqrt(9) will map to 3.. never -3. If Sqrt(9) could be either -3 OR 3, it wouldn't be a function. Even though (-3)^2 = 9 = (3)^2, the root function is defined to take positive values and produce positive values.

    Edit: the √(-2)² is not -2, but 2 btw :P
    You probably meant (-2)² = √4 = 2²

    This is exactly what you kind of said.. sqrt( (-2)^2 ) is indeed 2 since (-2)^2 gives us 4, and by the definition of the function, we will get the positive possible "root" only.

    "You probably meant (-2)² = √4 = 2²" You probably made some typing mistake here.. (-2)^2 = sqrt(4) = 2^2?? 4 = 2 = 4? I don't know
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?
Similar Discussions: One equals minus one?
  1. Negative one equals one (Replies: 10)

  2. Function one to one (Replies: 9)