Optimizing a milling operation

  • Thread starter aeb2335
  • Start date
In summary, the person was trying to figure out what feed rate and power they should use for a CNC machine to cut 2024 AL. They lost the book they took a class on a long time ago, and were looking for recommendations. They found some arbitrarily recommended values for the chip load and power needed, but they want to know what other factors should be taken into account.
  • #1
aeb2335
26
0
Kind of off the wall question but here it goes:

I am trying to figure if my set up for a CNC machine is one that will work and what feed rate I should use to cut 2024 AL. Right now ( as per the free mount I got with the kit ) I am using a dremel 300 with a 1/8 in tungsten carbide bit from dremel. The dremel was not happy and sounded horrid (I have done proper milling before so I am positive it was not a good noise).

My thoughts were that I should either get a different bit (one that is an actual end mill) or just not use the dremel and get something with some more horsepower. But in order to do that I need a "framework" of equations or a resource that will point me in the right direction.

I remember I took a class some time back that had a way of using a combination of the taylor tool life equation and some other related manufacturing equations to figure out the optimal speed feed and horsepower for milling (and turning) operations. I have lost the book for that course though and my google searches have been unsuccessful.

Things I know are involved and would like the relationships between:

Chip load
number of flutes
material removal rate
cutter dia
RPM
HP
Hardness
machine-ability rating
and feed rate



Thanks so much
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
1) this is not a physics question
2) do you have values (off a manual or anythiing) for recommended tooth load, RPM, or surface speed? If yes, you can easily calculate everything else.
 
  • #3
I would debate you on your assertion that this is not a physics question.

I did eventually find some somewhat arbitrarily recommended values for the chip load. The dremel only puts out about 138 watts and has a range of 5000-35000 RPM but again that's not helpful. Yes you could easily figure out how much material could be removed but the question becomes is it effective and optimal i.e what's cost to the cutter and heat.

Anyway,

There should be a way of calculating the power needed in a cutter to remove a material at a certain rate while also accounting for the thermal component of the operation. Which I would assume involves the material properties of the work piece i.e modulus of elasticity, brinelle hardness etc.
 
  • #4
Someone makes a kit to turn a dremel into a CNC? It seems absurd, because a dremel isn't made to take side loads like that. The average drill press isn't made to handle milling side loads, and a drill press is vastly sturdier than a dremel.
 
  • #5
Agreed

The dremel truly made for wood working and small DIY and is not made for this it was more of a free gag.

The way the tool attaches to the gantry however, you can bolt on something far more beefy including a 3 HP dedicated router you or can use a "normal" spindle.

But before I spend money on new tools etc. it would be really nice to be able to say given X material this is the power, feed rate and cutter that would be best suited for the operation so the original question still stands.
 
  • #7
There's something called "specific cutting energy" that gives the work required to remove a certain volume of material, and knowing your removal rate you can use this to determine the power required by the machine, and knowing your cutting speeds, the force also.

But it is BS since it matters what type of chips you are making. In engineering they assume this "specific cutting energy" to be a constant, but engineering=bs so I wouldn't trust any of that.
 
  • #8
A dremel does not have properly preloaded bearings and you will destroy it by trying to mill. You have likely damaged the bearings already.

A three flute 1/8th endmill in aluminium could safely cut at around 60IPM at 15-20,000RPM and as fast as 200IPM at 30,000RPM given proper geometry, engagement, chip evacuation, cooling etc. You would need less than 1/2HP to cut with a 1/8" endmill.

This is really not a physics question since there are far too many factors to come up with a meaningful answer. Even the fancy software just looks up your end-mill in a manufacturer provided database of tested feeds and speeds and de-rates according to your machine specs. I would recommend no more than 8000RPM and 12IPM until you know what you are doing. In general, you should change the RPM and IPM proportionally because if you go too slow the cutter will rub instead of "peeling" off metal and will heat up extremely fast.

Go to cnczone and look around. If you want something that can cut well with small bits look into a water cooled chinese spindle. They have a 2.2KW model that shreds aluminium, wood, composites, plastic etc.

Routers tend to have high runout which will cause problems milling metal with small bits but a decent router would do an okay job with a 1/8" bit.
 

What factors should I consider when optimizing a milling operation?

Some key factors to consider when optimizing a milling operation include the type of material being milled, the desired surface finish, the cutting tool and cutting parameters, and the machine and workholding setup.

How can I improve the efficiency of my milling operation?

Efficiency can be improved by reducing the amount of material being removed, increasing the cutting speed, and minimizing tool wear. Proper tool selection and use of high-performance cutting tools can also help improve efficiency.

What are some common challenges in optimizing a milling operation?

Some common challenges in optimizing a milling operation include maintaining tight tolerances, achieving a desired surface finish, managing chip evacuation, and avoiding tool breakage.

What is the role of coolant in optimizing a milling operation?

Coolant is essential for maintaining proper cutting temperatures and prolonging tool life in a milling operation. It also helps with chip evacuation and can improve surface finish.

How can I monitor and track the performance of my milling operation?

There are several ways to monitor and track the performance of a milling operation, including measuring tool wear, recording cutting parameters and speeds, and using advanced monitoring systems such as vibration analysis or thermal imaging.

Similar threads

  • DIY Projects
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
22
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
909
  • Electromagnetism
2
Replies
42
Views
563
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Nuclear Engineering
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
19
Views
4K
Back
Top