Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Paper bend in space

  1. May 10, 2005 #1
    Questions arise in my high school physics class about all sorts of things. A current thought question had to do with a piece of paper in space and a constant force being supplied at its center, perhaps by an alien or astronauts finger tip. Would the outer edges of the paper bend from the center of contact in the opposite direction of motion. There are no air particles distributing a resistance force, however would the localized force push the paper along in space as a flat sheet or more like what we would experience on earth. By bringing in Newtons III Law it would appear that the paper will move along as a flat sheet since there is no resisting force, however, earthbound experience and logic makes it hard to believe that this would be true. For sake of discussion, lets assume that there are no forces due to solar winds or gravitation towards another object.
  2. jcsd
  3. May 10, 2005 #2
    I reckon the paper would still bend. Paper is not a rigid body, so if a force is applied it will still deform. After this though it will travel forever. Or at least until it hits something. :D

    Interesting question though.
  4. May 10, 2005 #3


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Education Advisor

    The paper would still "bend" because of its mass and thus, inertia, distributed over the size of the paper.

  5. May 10, 2005 #4


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Welcome to Physics Forums, pete worthington!

    How about some variations? What if the paper were an extremely thin sheet of plastic, sort of gladwrap on anorexia? What if it were super-hardened steel? How about something like putty, or glass just below melting point? What if the 'finger tip' force were a feather, or a stream of tiny glass beads? or a beam of cold neutrons? or photons?? What if the 'finger' was very hot, and raised the point of contact to above the 'paper's' melting point (or otherwise cause the 'point' of contact to suffer a drastic drop in 'mechanical strength')?

    And how much 'flapping' would the paper do? What would that flapping depend upon?
  6. May 10, 2005 #5
    I'm thinking it will bend regardless because the deformation has to propogate through the material. You are immediately pushing a point, and that point will pull its paper-atom buddies with it, but that pull isnt instantaneous, so there will be a brief bend. Come to think of it, I think some oscillating will be taking place.
  7. May 11, 2005 #6
    i think the bend will be very small on an atomic level for the same reasons that whoozum attributed but i doubt whether there will be ossilation if the force is constant . if the force is instantaneous then i guess there will be oscillation since elastic forces(?) caused the deformation of the bonds in the first place.
  8. May 11, 2005 #7
    Suppose the force you apply accelerates the paper at g (9.8m/s2). Then the paper will do pretty much what a sheet of paper does when you set it on a finger that's pointing up.

    Not bad huh?
  9. May 11, 2005 #8
    True, but I think the initial problem was an instantaneous force, rather than a continued force. If the force is instantaneous then I proposed that the deformation would lead to oscillations where the center and the edges oscillate to a small extent in displacement from the CM.

    That was genius jdavel :)
  10. May 11, 2005 #9
    to me it seems,it will bend upward due to inertia
  11. May 11, 2005 #10
    For the edges to bend upwards (farther than the deformation of the center) they would need a force applied greater than the force of the finger on the center, how is that feasible?
  12. May 11, 2005 #11
    no,u did not understand me,they'll appear to bend upwards as seen from the centre of the paper.
  13. May 11, 2005 #12
    I still dont understand your perspective.

    Say the paper lies on the xy plane. The instant the force is applied in the positive z direction, the center is lifted above the xy plane, while the force still needs to propogate through the medium to lift the rest of the paper. Once the center has lifted, the force begins propogating and travels like a shockwave through the rest of the paper, lifting it in what looks like a conic fashion. Once the wave reaches the edges, the entire page will be moving with constant velocity in the positive z direction.

    However, given some loss in energy transfer through the paper, the edges will not accelerate at the same speed as the center, even after the tiny time delay (of propagation). The effects of this im not sure.
  14. May 11, 2005 #13
    what I have been saying is what u have been saying till
    the wave reaches the edges
  15. May 11, 2005 #14
    Until the wave reaches the edges, the edges are below the center, not above.
  16. May 11, 2005 #15
    but in the starting,when the waves have just begun to travel,the edges are above
  17. May 11, 2005 #16
    Can you do some explaining as to why the edges would be above. You say you are agreeing with my proposition but it looks like you are disagreeing with it. The edges cant be above because in the initial inertial frame where the paper was stationary and completely flat the force applied to the center displaces the center immediately and then travels to the rest of the paper. Saying the edges are above the center means that the force through the center got to the edges before the center (or were more powerful than the force at the center).
  18. May 11, 2005 #17
    constant force is assumed. jdavel has a great thought analogy but what about atmospheric pressure. all those piled up molecules and dust particles pushing in on all areas/surfaces of the paper except where your finger tip touches? Isn't that point of contact creating an unequal force distribution on the paper?
  19. May 13, 2005 #18
    I think the paper would take on a wave shape, higher in the center (of where we touch it) and dropping off towards the edges. It would distort and be effected by the shape of the paper also;square, rectangular, round, etc. The wave size would be determined by how hard we push and for how far.

    A question: how would the conditions in space effect the paper? I mean the extreme cold and lack of pressure specifically.
  20. May 17, 2005 #19
    i just read through this thread (breifly, so excuse me if I repeat something), and couldnt resit posting my opinion....

    I belive that the paper will Not bend... argument are given that it has a distribution of mass, and that this will cause the paper to bend. But that isnt true at all, as mass itself doenst bend this, or is a force. It is with gravtitation (any acceleation) that makes the mass "get weight".

    So, if a paper is in space, and there is actually no need to keep an alien finger or somethign to keep it up (whichever direction that is ), as there is no force exerting on it. But IF we now put a finger there, we are not "lifiting" but rather pushing it. See it as we have a block on a friction-free surface and it is at rest. It doesnt need any force or finger to remain at rest.

    EDIT: didnt get expressed what i wanted to say :).... However, just thotght if a similar question. When Superman flies through space, should his hair "wirl" (dont know the english word really)... Like when you are driving a cab or motrobike, your har "wirls"
    Last edited: May 17, 2005
  21. May 17, 2005 #20


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    OK, replace the paper with a whole lot of tiny balls of tungsten, each of which is welded to (say) six 'massless' springs (and no spring is a 'loose end'; each end is attached to a W ball).

    You 'push' on one of the tiny W balls ... what happens?
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook