1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: PDE question: Eigenvalues

  1. Mar 20, 2012 #1
    1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
    Let λ_n denote the nth eigenvalue for the problem:

    -Δu = λu in A, u=0 on ∂A (*)

    which is obtained by minimizing the Rayleigh quotient over all non-zero functions that vanish on ∂A and are orthogonal to the first n-1 eigenfunctions.

    (i) Show that (*) has no other eigenvalues

    (ii) Show that one can find a non-negative eigenfunction for the first eigenvalue of (*). Such an eigenfunction is also known as a ground state.
    Hint: If w is an eigenfunction that changes sign, then α=max(w,0) and β=min(w,0) are nonzero but of one sign; relate their Rayleigh quotients with that of their sum α+β=w

    Now let some real number 'a' be fixed and f(x) a given smooth function. Consider the problem:

    -Δu = au + f in A, u=0 on ∂A (**)

    (iii) Show (**) has no solution when a = λ_k is an eigenvalue of (*) and f is not orthogonal to the corresponding eigenfunction u_k.

    (iv) Let f(x) be a given smooth function and suppose a is not an eigenvalue of (*). Find the unique solution of the problem (**). Hint: the solution is a linear combination of the eigenfunctions u_k by completeness, so you need only determine the coefficients.

    2. Relevant equations

    3. The attempt at a solution
    Hi guys,

    Thanks for looking at my problem, I am a bit stuck on this particular one! We didn't do much about eigenvalues (with regard to pde's) in class and I haven't been able to find any books that give examples other than the basic theorems. Here's what I've done so far:

    (i) Use proof by contradiction. Let λ* be some other eigenvalue, ie λ_n < λ* < λ_(n+1)

    thus -Δu = λ*u

    for u a corresponding eigenfunction.

    The Rayleigh quotient is:

    R(u) = ( ∫|∇u|^2 ) / ( ∫∇u^2 )

    Suppose R(u) attains a minimum over the set:

    X_n = { u ∊ C^2(A): u=0 on ∂A, u ≢0 and u⊥u_1, ..,u_(n-1) }
    Then any function that minimizes R(u) over X_n is an eigenfunction u_n, with eigenvalue λ_n,

    where λ_n = min R(u), for u ∊ X_n.

    Now we want to show that λ* is not of this form i.e. minimizes R(u) but not over the set as outlined above.
    But if λ* is indeed an eigenvalue, and minimizes R(u), with corresponding eigenfunction u* say, then there will be some u ∊ {u_1, u_2, .... , u_n ... }, u_k, say, such that u_k ⊥ u*.
    But then u_k will be orthogonal to u_1, u_2, ..., u_(k-1), and then so will u*.

    But u* cannot be a member of this set.
    And this is a contradiction.

    Thus all λ are indeed of the required form.

    I don’t know if this is right (I think I may have left out something, it just seems a bit straightforward...) I would be really grateful if you could tell me if it is?

    By definition of the Rayleigh quotient,

    R(α) = ( ∫|∇ α |^2 ) / ( ∫∇ α ^2 )


    R(β) = ( ∫|∇ β |^2 ) / ( ∫∇ β ^2 )


    R(α +β) = ( ∫|∇ α |^2 + 2∫ ∇ α .∇ β + ∫|∇ β |^2 ) / ∫( α^2 + 2αβ + β^2)

    But then I’m stuck as to how to relate them, is it a case of minimizing R(α +β)?.

    If a= λ_k is an eigenvalue of (*), then:

    -Δu = au

    But -Δu = au+f

    So then au = au+f, unless f orthogonal (in which case it vanishes).
    So this gives us a contradiction otherwise.

    I know that seems really brief, but it is making sense in my head, I think I’m just not articulating it properly. Please could someone give me a point in the right direction?

    I actually have no idea how to go about solving this one. How do I go about setting up the equation and solving the coefficients?

    Thank you so much for looking at this and I would really appreciate any hints or pointers you could give me. Thanks again.
  2. jcsd
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Can you offer guidance or do you also need help?
Draft saved Draft deleted