Percentage errors

  • Thread starter lavster
  • Start date
  • #1
lavster
217
0
How can you get positive and negative errors to be different in magnitude?

for example -

when calculating the error of the area of an annulus from two circular areas (ie subtracting one from the other, why is the positive error greater than the negative error

Thanks
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Naty1
5,607
40
because the denominators are different...

like, say, you have $100 invested and you lose $20...that's a $20 loss...
Now you have $80...What percentage gain do you need to get your $20 back...
20/80 is 25%.

figures don't lie, but liars figure!
 
  • #3
lavster
217
0
i understand the money analogy, but not when talking about the areas - sorry! :S we are only subtracting once
 
  • #4
mathman
Science Advisor
8,088
550
i understand the money analogy, but not when talking about the areas - sorry! :S we are only subtracting once

Could you illustrate by an example what you are concerned about?
 
  • #5
36,250
13,308
Imagine a square where both sides are known with a precision of 10% - they might be 10% shorter or 10% longer, but not more. What is the maximal deviation?

Larger area: Both sides 10% longer, total area 1.1^2 = 1.21 of the original area (21% more).
Smaller area: Both sides 10% shorter, total area 0.9^2 = 0.81 of the original area (19% less).
Do you see the difference?
 
  • #6
mathman
Science Advisor
8,088
550
Imagine a square where both sides are known with a precision of 10% - they might be 10% shorter or 10% longer, but not more. What is the maximal deviation?

Larger area: Both sides 10% longer, total area 1.1^2 = 1.21 of the original area (21% more).
Smaller area: Both sides 10% shorter, total area 0.9^2 = 0.81 of the original area (19% less).
Do you see the difference?

I see the difference, but why do you see this as a problem?
 
  • #7
Khashishi
Science Advisor
2,815
493
The error depends on how the measurement was taken and what analysis was done. When you do math on the measurement, the errors will change shape. If you measure a circle's radius with a ruler with a symmetric error in the length, then the error in the area is not symmetric, because area goes as length squared.
 
  • #8
36,250
13,308
I see the difference, but why do you see this as a problem?
Where did I say that it is a problem?
I just said that you can get asymmetric uncertainties in this way.
 
  • #9
lavster
217
0
ah great :) thanks :)
 
Top