Percentage problem

  • Thread starter galois
  • Start date
  • #1
8
0
99% of the people in a room are men. How many men would have to leave the room in order for this percentage to decrease to 98%? It is known that the number of women in the room is 3.

I get stuck on this one.I'm not sure if my result is good i got 2.97 !
Please help,thank you!
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
1,331
40
No, your solution is not close.

How many people are there total? Answer me that first.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #3
SteamKing
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
12,796
1,668
It's chopping off that 0.03 of the third guy which could be a problem.

Percentage problems are like proportion problems, they just use a different way to express the proportion, with a percentage instead of a ratio.

You know the number of women in the room, but you don't know the number of men. Call the number of men 'x' and write an equation which expresses the original percentage of men to the total number of men and women. You should be able to solve this equation for the number of men. Write another equation, using the second percentage and solve it. The difference in the values of 'x' from the two equations will be the number of men asked to leave.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #4
8
0
No, your solution is not close.

How many people are there total? Answer me that first.
There are 3 women in the room,so they make 1% of people in the room.That means there are 300 in total.
 
  • #5
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
There are 3 women in the room,so they make 1% of people in the room.That means there are 300 in total.
So that means there are 297 males in the room.
We know that 1% = 3, and 99-98 =1 So how many man will have to leave the room?

No need of doing many calculation here.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #6
8
0
So that means there are 297 males in the room.
We know that 1% = 3, and 99-98 =1 So how many man will have to leave the room?

No need of doing many calculation here.
3 1
--- = --- , 300 = x
x 100

297 of them men. For the same 3 women to make up 2% of a room, there
have to be 150 people in the room,

3 2
--- = --- , 300 = 2x , 150 = x
x 100

147 of them men. 150 men have to leave the room I think.
 
  • #7
8
0
It's chopping off that 0.03 of the third guy which could be a problem.

Percentage problems are like proportion problems, they just use a different way to express the proportion, with a percentage instead of a ratio.

You know the number of women in the room, but you don't know the number of men. Call the number of men 'x' and write an equation which expresses the original percentage of men to the total number of men and women. You should be able to solve this equation for the number of men. Write another equation, using the second percentage and solve it. The difference in the values of 'x' from the two equations will be the number of men asked to leave.
99:x=100:300
29700=100x
x=297

98:x=100:300
29400=100x
x=294

297-294=3

294 is 98% of 297. Is this right ?
 
  • #8
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
Yes, the answer is 3.
294 is 98% of 297. Is this right ?
No 294 is 98% of 300.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #9
8
0
Yes, the answer is 3.


No 294 is 98% of 300.
My bad,can you please write the proportions for me,i understand what SteamKing means.
 
  • #10
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
99:x=100:300
29700=100x
x=297

98:x=100:300
29400=100x
x=294

297-294=3
This is how you do it.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #11
8
0
This is how you do it.
I'm confused now.Can you please write the solution. sorry if i'm troubling you.
 
  • #12
8
0
Please I need the result really.If i knew how to solve it I wouldn't ask you,so please write how to solve this.I do not want to be rude. Help please :D
 
  • #13
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
Let's see now. We have 300 people. 297 is male(99% of 300) and 3 is female.

Now ##\frac{98}{100} \times 300= 294 ##- This means that 98% of the people is 294.
The difference between 297-294 is 3

So when 3 males get out, the percentage of males will change from 99% to 98%.


The total number of people will decrease from 300 to 297

Now, what is the other 2 percent? This made me confused too. From where did you get this question?
 
  • #14
8
0
Let's see now. We have 300 people. 297 is male(99% of 300) and 3 is female.

Now ##\frac{98}{100} \times 300= 294 ##- This means that 98% of the people is 294.
The difference between 297-294 is 3

So when 3 males get out, the percentage of males will change from 99% to 98%.


The total number of people will decrease from 300 to 297

Now, what is the other 2 percent? This made me confused too. From where did you get this question?
Yes i get to this point to,but can't finish it i have some ideas,but I'm not sure if they are right.I got this problem from my professor to solve.

Do you think this could be the solution

3 1
--- = --- , 300 = x
x 100

297 of them men. For the same 3 women to make up 2% of a room, there
have to be 150 people in the room,

3 2
--- = --- , 300 = 2x , 150 = x
x 100

147 of them men. 150 men have to leave the room I think.
 
Last edited:
  • #15
1,331
40
Yes, the answer is 150, you have worked the problem exactly correct.

Adjacent seems to be confused here. 3 males getting out does not change the percentage to 98% because you don't have 300 people any more. 98% of 300 and 98% of some changed total are different animals.

I did it differently, but it amounts to the same thing, and I think your solution is much more clever, because while I looked at the men (which is a changing value) you looked at the women, which would not change, to solve the same problem. This was a very good thing you did.

297 / 300 = .99,

We would like to subtract an "x" from the numerator and denominator because men leaving decreases the number of men, 297, and the number of people, 300.

So I solved the equation:
(297-x)/(300-x) = .98
Which quickly yields x = 150.

This is how I instinctively solved it, but again, I like what you did better.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #16
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
Yes, the answer is 150, you have worked the problem exactly correct.
I don't think so. I didn't understand his workings.
If 150 people left the room then there should be 147 men in the room left.
--> ##\frac{147}{297} \times 100=49.494949...##
--> That means the percentage of men in the room is 49.494949...%
Then the percentage of women is calculated like this:##\frac{3}{297} \times 100=1.1010101...%##
So the total percentage is 50.5050505...%?
:confused:
 
  • #17
1,331
40
I don't think so. I didn't understand his workings.
If 150 people left the room then there should be 147 men in the room left.
--> ##\frac{147}{297} \times 100=49.494949...##
--> That means the percentage of men in the room is 49.494949...%
Then the percentage of women is calculated like this:##\frac{3}{297} \times 100=1.1010101...%##
So the total percentage is 50.5050505...%?
:confused:
No, it is clear. Galois reasoned that the static number of women, 3, will be 2% of the new total. Thus, the new total is 150. Therefore the total decreased by (300 - 150) = 150. Done.

If 150 men leave the room, there are (297-150) = 147 men in the room. If 150 men leave the room then there are (300-150) = 150 people left in the room total. 147 is 98% of 150. What is your objection? The expressions you wrote aren't about anything in this problem.
 
Last edited:
  • #18
adjacent
Gold Member
1,549
63
No, it is clear. Galois reasoned that the static number of women, 3, will be 2% of the new total. Thus, the new total is 150. Therefore the total decreased by (300 - 150) = 150. Done.

If 150 men leave the room, there are (297-150) = 147 men in the room. If 150 men leave the room then there are (300-150) = 150 people left in the room total. 147 is 98% of 150. What is your objection?
Oh, I got confused.I understand now. Sorry for making you confused too, galois! :redface:.
 

Related Threads on Percentage problem

  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
677
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
707
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
786
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
971
Top