How Can We Improve the Intellectual Sophistication of Online Forums?

[coberst]

I occasionally surf the secular forums and it seems to me that a vast majority of the threads are either AB (adolescent banter) or PC (philosophically correct). Most of this majority is AB threads and probably ten percent are PC threads wherein the participants argue over scholastic esoterica.

There was once a popular TV commercial that displayed an old Indian man traveling down the nation’s waterways teary eyed as he viewed the trash and effluents that were destroying a beautiful nature.

I felt somewhat like the Old Indian when I observed these forums because I think we waste a valuable opportunity to make it so much better than that.

I do not propose that we attempt to change the ABs but I do suggest that the PCs could be modified to better channel that displayed talent to a more positive end.

The purpose for such a change is to advance the intellectual sophistication of our fellow citizens. I would suggest C-SPAN as an example that we might try to emulate. I do not suggest that we emulate any of the techniques or processes of C-SPAN but that we try to be guided by that same purpose. It seems to me that C-SPAN is a shining example of what can be accomplished by one small segment of a giant unenlightened medium.

We all seem to have a negative angel and a positive angel; our negative angel seems to be our default position. Just for a little while try to corral your negative angel. There will always be many opportunities to stomp on anything positive that might develop. If we start negative our ego will fight any attempt to flip-flop.

 

[balkan]

often annoyance of the AB's could prolly be avoided by reducing the lix count, i.e. being more literal... i, myself, am sick and tired of people flowering quite simple examples and concepts with an endless amount of unneccessary and extravangant words to inflate their egos, without it contributing in any sense to the conversation...

 

[R0man]

One way to improve the intellectual sophistication of online forums is to encourage more thoughtful and meaningful discussions. This can be achieved by setting guidelines for participants and moderators to follow, such as avoiding personal attacks and staying on topic. Additionally, moderators can play an important role in steering discussions towards more intellectual topics and discouraging frivolous or repetitive threads.

Another way to improve the sophistication of online forums is to provide resources and materials for participants to educate themselves on various topics. This can include recommended readings, videos, or other sources that can help broaden their knowledge and perspectives.

Furthermore, it is important to create a culture of open-mindedness and respect for differing opinions. This can be achieved by promoting active listening and encouraging participants to consider different viewpoints. It is also important to have moderators who are unbiased and fair in their decision-making.

In addition, it may be helpful to have designated experts or professionals in specific fields participate in discussions and provide their insights. This can add credibility and elevate the level of discourse in the forum.

Lastly, it is important for participants to be mindful of their language and tone when engaging in discussions. Using respectful and thoughtful language can go a long way in promoting a more sophisticated and productive conversation.

In conclusion, improving the intellectual sophistication of online forums requires a collective effort from both participants and moderators. By setting guidelines, providing resources, promoting open-mindedness, and being mindful of language, we can create a more intellectually stimulating and enriching environment for discussions. Let's strive to make online forums a platform for meaningful and thought-provoking discussions rather than a breeding ground for adolescent banter or philosophical correctness.