# Proving A subspace

nautolian
1. Let V={X $\in$ R2 : (1 2) X= (0)}
..........................(3 4) ..... (0)
Show that V is a subspace of R^2 with the usual operations. What is the dimension of V

2. Homework Equations

3. I am really kind of lost, the statement seems to make no sense. X is in R but it also = the matrix [1 2, 3 4] but also equals the matrix [0,0]?
Is v not a subspace of R^2 because it equals the zero vector? Thanks for the help.

Last edited by a moderator:

Mentor
1. Let V={X $\in$ R2 : (1 2) X= (0)}
..........................(3 4) ..... (0)
Show that V is a subspace of R^2 with the usual operations. What is the dimension of V

2. Homework Equations

3. I am really kind of lost, the statement seems to make no sense. X is in R
No, X is a vector in R2.
but it also = the matrix [1 2, 3 4]
No, this is a 2 x 2 matrix, so it can't possibly be equal to a vector in R2.
but also equals the matrix [0,0]?
No again.

$$\begin{bmatrix}1 & 2 \\ 3 & 4\end{bmatrix}$$
Let's call it A

$$\begin{bmatrix}x_1 \\ x_2\end{bmatrix}$$

V is all of the vectors in R2 such that Ax = 0, where 0 is the zero vector in R2.
Is v not a subspace of R^2 because it equals the zero vector? Thanks for the help.

nautolian
Isn't the only solution to that equation [0,0]? Hence, it is not a subspace because the only solution is the zero vector? Thanks again

Mentor
Isn't the only solution to that equation [0,0]?
Maybe. Why do you think so?
Hence, it is not a subspace because the only solution is the zero vector?
A set with only the zero vector in it is a subspace of whatever space it's in.
Thanks again

nautolian
So essentially the dimension is then 1 because the basis is the zero vector? Is that possible and I think so because reducing the matrix [1 2, 3 4] gives the identity which set to 0 means that the only solution is at x=[0,0]

Mentor
So essentially the dimension is then 1 because the basis is the zero vector? Is that possible and I think so because reducing the matrix [1 2, 3 4] gives the identity which set to 0 means that the only solution is at x=[0,0]
You're mostly on track here. Since the basis for V is just the zero vector, the dimension of V is zero, not one. Your matrix A maps every nonzero vector in R to some other nonzero vector.

nautolian
Thanks! Okay, so how would I go about proving V is a subspace of R^2 though? Like in terms of addition and multiplication being closed? Do I just pretend that two vectors in V are [a,b] and [c,d]??