Quantum Entanglement and FTL Information transfer

In summary, this experiment does not seem to provide a way to send information faster than the speed of light.
  • #1
FreshBranes
1
0
First post.

There's something I don't quite understand about quantum entanglement and I'm hoping someone here can put me right. When I first heard about the Aspect experiment, I thought that it had to open the way forward for faster-than-light information transfer as follows:

Bob is on Earth and Alice is on Saturn. On Earth, Bob sets up his equipment to entangle photons, of which one half get sent to Alice. The other half stay on Earth but are effectively trapped by a cunning set of mirrors.

A few hours later, Bob checks his watch to ensure that the photons are about to arrive at Saturn. Bob then writes a message in binary to Alice. He dooes this by either measuring the x-axis spin of the first photon, or not observing it at all. He then repeats with the next photon etc.

On Saturn, Alice has a equipment setup for measuring the y-axis spin of the photons she's received. Now, either she can make a measurement or she can't - in the exact same sequence that Bob has been observing / not observing on Earth. So effectively she's receiving Bob's binary communication. And rather than travel at light speed, hasn't the binary code traveled instantaneously??

Can anyone shed some light on this?

[Don't get me wrong - I don't think I've discovered FTL information transfer or anything, I just want to correct my deficiency in understanding quantum entanglement and relatvistic effects?]
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
From your description, it didn't look like Bob got his particles with any particular orientation, so we have to assume the pairs were uniformly distributed across all angles. So Bob measures the spin of on particle in each pair around the x-axis, and I presume gets the standard three streams out, corresponding to +1, 0, and -1. Bob modulates the beam by turning the meansurement on and off. So a pulse of uniform distributions denotes bit 0 and a pulse of +1,0,-1 on the x-axis represents a bit 1.

Now Alice looks at her particles. They are also modulated, but in her case the different beams are all mixed together. How does she demodulate them? You say she measures the y-component. But a normal experiment shows that doing that on particles that have previously experienced an x-measurement should randomize the spins back to uniform distribution.

The key is that you get only one shot at the entangled state. Anything you do to configure it collapses the wavefunction and destroys the entanglement.
 
  • #3
In the experiment you describe, Bob encodes his information by either performing a measurement or not. Then you assume that Alice knows to either perform the mesurement or not in the same sequence that Bob did. Hence she already knew his information before the experiment started and can gain no information from it.

A slightly more sophisticated version of your experiment is as follows. Suppose Bob wishes to transmit a 0 to Alice. To do this he measures the x component of spin on his half of the EPR pairs until he gets spin up. If he wanted to transmit a 1 then he does the same thing except this time he waits for spin down.

No information is transmitted to Alice in this experiment, since any measurements she does on her EPR pairs have completely random outcomes and she does not know which one of the EPR pairs was used to encode the bit. However, if Bob tells Alice which EPR pair was used to encode the bit then she can find out what Bob's bit was by measuring the x-component of spin on her half of that pair. Notice that this transmission from Bob requires a signal, which cannot travel faster than the speed of light.

This is completely useless for faster-than-light communication, but notice that, if Alice and Bob really did share EPR pairs, no-one else would be able to determine Bob's bit. Thus, we have a kind of secure cryptography. The subtlety is that Alice and Bob must be certain that they really did share EPR pairs for this to work, i.e. that no-one tampered with the EPR particle whilst it was on its way to Alice. This is subtle because there is no measurement on a single pair that Alice or Bob could make to confirm this. However, they can get around this by selecting a random sample of their pairs and doing a Bell-type experiment on them. If they violate the Bell inequalities by a large enough amount, then one can show that this sort of cryptography really is secure.
 

What is quantum entanglement?

Quantum entanglement is a phenomenon observed in quantum physics where two particles become correlated in such a way that the state of one particle is dependent on the state of the other, even when they are separated by large distances. This correlation is not affected by time or space, making it a mysterious and intriguing aspect of quantum mechanics.

How does quantum entanglement work?

In quantum entanglement, two particles are linked together in a way that their properties, such as spin or polarization, are dependent on each other. This happens because of the way particles are described in quantum mechanics, where they exist in multiple states simultaneously until they are observed. When one particle is observed and its state is determined, the other particle's state is also determined, regardless of how far apart they are.

What is FTL information transfer?

FTL (faster-than-light) information transfer refers to the hypothetical ability to communicate or transmit information faster than the speed of light. In the context of quantum entanglement, it suggests that information can be transmitted between entangled particles instantaneously, even if they are separated by vast distances.

Is FTL information transfer possible?

Currently, there is no scientific evidence to suggest that FTL information transfer is possible. While quantum entanglement allows for instantaneous communication between particles, this does not necessarily mean that information can be transmitted faster than the speed of light. The theory of relativity, which has been extensively tested, states that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light.

What are the potential applications of quantum entanglement and FTL information transfer?

Quantum entanglement and FTL information transfer have the potential to revolutionize communication and computing technologies. They could enable secure and instantaneous communication, as well as more powerful and efficient quantum computers. However, much more research and development is needed before these technologies can become a reality.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
723
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
5
Views
678
Replies
41
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
656
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
593
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
719
Replies
1
Views
616
Back
Top