When I try to apply the force transformation (the 3 vector one) to the describe following situation, I find a result that I can't make sense of. Hopefully someone can tell me what I'm doing wrong. Suppose observers A and B are in inertial frames, and B travels in the +x direction relative to A. Object C is initially at rest relative to A, and is immediately next to A. In B's frame object C initially travels in the -x direction along with A.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Now consider what happens when an unbalanced force is exerted on object C in the +y direction when the force is described in the reference frame of A.

The object will accelerate in the +y direction when it is described in A's frame. I would think that the object must accelerate only in the +y direction in B's frame also (it cannot accelerate in the +x or -x direction), otherwise we would have a paradox. But once the object is moving in the +y direction relative to A and B, the relativistic transformation for the x component of force in B's frame suggests that the x component of force in B's frame will not be zero - even though the x component of force is zero in A's frame! This arises because the "power term" (the dot product of the force on object C in A's frame and the velocity of C in A's frame) that is present in the transformation will not be equal to zero. But this doesn't make sense to me. You can't have an x component of force in B's frame in this situation when there is no x component of force in A's frame; the object can't have an

x- component of acceleration in B's frame when it has no x-component of acceleration in A's frame. I suspect the only way out of this mess is that the dot product term in the force transformation must be zero for some reason, but I don't see why from the way that this thought experiment has been described. Can anyone please help?

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Question on applying the force transform in a specific case

Tags:

Loading...

Similar Threads - Question applying force | Date |
---|---|

I Some geometry questions re Swartzchild metric | Yesterday at 9:27 AM |

B Causality Question | Feb 23, 2018 |

I A question about the relativistic energy dispersion relation | Feb 20, 2018 |

Question about applying the Lorentz Transformation to velocity 4-vectors | Mar 20, 2009 |

Quick question on where to apply time dilation. | Apr 3, 2004 |

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**