Replacing Expansion Valve with Small Diameter Tube for Efficient Home AC Cooling

In summary: Yes, it will provide the same cooling effect as the orifice tube. However, it will be more efficient because it will use less energy.
  • #1
Buzzworks
69
1
For example in typical window-type home air conditioning:

-If I remove the expansion valve and replace the valve with a small diameter tube to constrict the flow of gas so that the average gas pressure difference between the condenser and evaporator coils are the same as when you had expansion valve, will I get the same amount of cooling?

-Will I still get cooling effect at all?

-If answers are both yes, why not use small diameter tubes so it will be simpler and with no moving parts?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
bump...

Or perhaps I may have posted this on the wrong section. Should be on engineering?
 
  • #3
I have experience with automotive air conditioning systems so I will speak to your question from that perspective

Automotive air conditioning systems use both types of systems depending on the vehicle. The small diameter tubes are called orifice tubes. Both systems work but there are design considerations for the rest of the system that prevent you from directly swapping one for the other.

In most orifice tube systems the compressor is cycled on and off based on low side pressure. In an R134a automotive system it would cycle on at about 40 psi and off at about 30. The reason for the lower pressure limit is to prevent the evaporator from getting so cold that water vapor freezes to it forming ice which would block air flow. In this type of system the accumulator must be on the low side of the system and serves a secondary function of separating liquid and gaseous refrigerant. If it were not there the compressor would be damaged by attempting to compress liquid refrigerant when it first engaged.

There are also a few systems out there that use an orifice tube with a variable displacement compressor to regulate low side pressure.

Orifice tube systems are cheaper to build but are less efficient because they allow the low side pressure to cycle over a much wider range then an expansion valve. In a time when EPA regulations are getting harder and harder to meet I suspect we'll be seeing fewer and fewer of these.
 
  • #4
Thanks mrspeedybob! Never knew about Orifice tubes! I just thought it up as replacement to the expansion valves. Probably my ignorance to the term and to the part itself stems from the fact I haven't encountered the term yet in my research in A/C systems. It's always expansion valves!

Thanks for pointing out both will work in providing cooling.
 
  • #5
crapworks said:
-If I remove the expansion valve and replace the valve with a small diameter tube to constrict the flow of gas so that the average gas pressure difference between the condenser and evaporator coils are the same as when you had expansion valve, will I get the same amount of cooling?
Well, you're basically replacing the expansion valve with a less efficient one. If the delta-T is the same but there is a lot more pipe, there is a lot more friction and a lot more loss.
-If answers are both yes, why not use small diameter tubes so it will be simpler and with no moving parts?
I'm not quite following: the expansion valve has no moving parts in it.
 
  • #6
russ_watters said:
Well, you're basically replacing the expansion valve with a less efficient one. If the delta-T is the same but there is a lot more pipe, there is a lot more friction and a lot more loss. I'm not quite following: the expansion valve has no moving parts in it.

Thanks Russ, now that you said that, I got thinking once more!

What if we don't use an orifice tube. What if we simply block the A/C coils at the same location you'd put an expansion valve or an orifice tube with a 2mm thick metal.

Then we make a pinhole in that metal. We'll call it 'pinhole restrictor'. Would that serve the purpose of an orifice tube of restricting gas flow to cause the pressure difference in the A/C coil? The pinhole will be of smaller area(less distance for the gases to traverse compared to tube), thus, causing less friction compared to the orifice tube.

Will it actually be more efficient than orifice tube and still provide the same cooling effect?
 

1. What is the purpose of an expansion valve?

An expansion valve is used in refrigeration and air conditioning systems to regulate the flow of refrigerant into the evaporator. It controls the amount of liquid refrigerant that enters the evaporator, allowing for efficient cooling.

2. How does an expansion valve work?

An expansion valve works by sensing the temperature and pressure of the refrigerant leaving the evaporator. It then adjusts the size of the valve opening to control the flow of refrigerant into the evaporator. This allows for precise regulation of the refrigerant and helps maintain the desired temperature in the system.

3. What are the different types of expansion valves?

There are three main types of expansion valves: thermostatic, electronic, and capillary tube. Thermostatic expansion valves use a temperature sensing bulb and a diaphragm to regulate the refrigerant flow. Electronic expansion valves use a motorized valve to control the refrigerant flow based on electronic signals. Capillary tube expansion valves use a long, narrow tube to control the flow of refrigerant into the evaporator.

4. How do you know if an expansion valve is faulty?

There are a few signs that may indicate a faulty expansion valve. These include insufficient cooling, excessive frost build-up on the evaporator, and high pressure on the low side of the system. If you suspect an issue with the expansion valve, it is best to consult a professional for diagnosis and repair.

5. Can an expansion valve be repaired or does it need to be replaced?

In most cases, an expansion valve will need to be replaced if it is faulty. However, if the issue is minor, such as a clogged valve, it may be possible to clean or repair it. It is always best to consult a professional for proper diagnosis and repair of an expansion valve.

Similar threads

  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
28
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
2
Replies
42
Views
8K
Replies
7
Views
947
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • General Engineering
Replies
6
Views
5K
Replies
77
Views
21K
Replies
11
Views
13K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top