Ratio of two unknown charges

1. Sep 7, 2009

jlwood13

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

You are given two unknown point charges, Q_1 and Q_2 . At a point on the line joining them, one-third of the way from Q_1 to Q_2 , the electric field is zero (see figure). The charges are separated by length, L.

What is the ratio of the charges Q1/Q2?

2. Relevant equations

F=k(Q1Q2)/r2

3. The attempt at a solution
I tried to put one charge in terms of the other, but I got lost and it seemed to be going nowhere. I'm stuck..

Attached Files:

• GIANCOLI.ch21.p41.jpg
File size:
4.9 KB
Views:
379
Last edited: Sep 7, 2009
2. Sep 7, 2009

kuruman

We cannot see the figure pending approval. What is the question? Do you know the separation between the charges?

In any case, you will need to say that the sum of the electric fields generated by the two charges at the given point is zero. Remember that electric fields are vectors, so what must be true for these two vectors to add up to zero?

3. Sep 7, 2009

jlwood13

I apologize. I added the relevant question.. If they add up to zero, they must be opposite in direction and proportional, correct?

4. Sep 7, 2009

jlwood13

I figured it out. Using E=kQ/r^2, set kQ1/(r1)^2=kQ2/(r2)^2 and solve for Q1/Q2. r1=l/3, r2=2l/3. Thanks for your help.