Really basic buoyancy question

  • Thread starter chiccaboom
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Buoyancy
In summary, when an object is submerged in a liquid, there is a net force upward due to the difference in pressure at the bottom and top of the object. This is because the pressure field varies with depth, so the bottom of the object experiences a higher upward force while the top experiences a lower downward force. This net buoyant force is what allows objects to float in a liquid. Additionally, the origin of this force is related to thermodynamics and the minimum internal energy state. The shape of the object can also affect the pressure difference at the top and bottom, but ultimately the net force will still be upward.
  • #1
chiccaboom
2
0
Hi All,

I'm having trouble understanding why exactly there is a net force upward when an object is submerged in a liquid. I thought the liquid exerts a force all around the object and thus cancels out...so how can there be a netforce from underneath the object?

I think my understanding of this concept is off...help please!

thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
chiccaboom said:
Hi All,

I'm having trouble understanding why exactly there is a net force upward when an object is submerged in a liquid. I thought the liquid exerts a force all around the object and thus cancels out...so how can there be a netforce from underneath the object?

I think my understanding of this concept is off...help please!

thanks!

The magnitude of the pressure field varies with depth. So the bottom of the object has a higer upward force since it is at a greater depth. The top of the object has a lower downward force as compared to the bottom since it is at a shallower depth.

Thus the net buoyant force is upward. This of course assumes a closed pressure field.

CS
 
  • #3
Basically how it works is that when an object is under water, the bottom part of that object is deeper than the top part, even if it's only by a tiny bit. Since the deeper you go, the more pressure water exerts on you, the bottom part feels more pressure than the top part, therefore there is a net force up on the object.

EDIT: And of course, I just used water arbitrarily. It can be any fluid. That's the reason why helium goes up in our atmosphere, it's lighter than our regular air.
 
  • #4
Another way of looking at it:

When you place an object in a liquid (let's say a boat being placed in water), it displaces a certain volume of that liquid. If the volume of water that the boat displaces is equal to or greater than the mass of the boat itself, the boat will float. If you are not using water as your liquid, don't forget to consider the density of the liquid you ARE working with.
 
  • #5
pressure is a thermodynamical quantity so the origin of this force is thermodynamics.

of all possible distrubitions, the distrubition that the object goes up has the minimum internal energy hence the origin of this force.

proof: increasing the temperature will also increase this force?
 
  • #6
GREAT! thanks everyone. You have helped immensely! yay!
 
  • #7
stewartcs said:
The magnitude of the pressure field varies with depth. So the bottom of the object has a higer upward force since it is at a greater depth. The top of the object has a lower downward force as compared to the bottom since it is at a shallower depth.

Thus the net buoyant force is upward. This of course assumes a closed pressure field.

CS

I never thought of it this way...

So if you have a hollow (closed, waterproof) tube of a reasonably light material and filled with air, and you put it underwater, does it come up faster if it's vertical and slower if it's horizontal?
 
  • #8
There's still going to be buoyancy from the difference in density between air and displaced water. But the horizontal tube will rise more slowly due to the increase in drag.
 
  • #9
Domenicaccio said:
I never thought of it this way...

So if you have a hollow (closed, waterproof) tube of a reasonably light material and filled with air, and you put it underwater, does it come up faster if it's vertical and slower if it's horizontal?

Neglecting the drag...they would rise at the same speed. The area (if the cylinder was perfectly vertical) of the bottom is smaller than the total area compared to the horizontal position. So the net buoyant force acting upward would be the same since the depth would be different (i.e. greater pressure acting on a smaller area = smaller pressure acting on greater area). The force from the pressure field acting perpendicular to the cylinder would be zero (again assuming it is perfectly vertical).

CS
 
  • #10
I can't type that fast Andy! :smile:
 
  • #11
...and if you put a hair-thin sheet of material (lighter than water) underwater, and position it flat horizontally, then it should almost stay there (or at least rise very very slowly) because there is almost no pressure difference between the bottom and the top?

PS Neglect imprecisions, assume it is perfectly flat.

(well in that case, if near-zero thin, there is no volume displaced either...)
 
  • #12
The bouyancy force is simply [tex]\Delta mg[/tex]. For a rigid body, regardless of how the mass is distributed in space, the force will be the same. An exceedingly thin (rigid) bubble-sheet-thing will have the same upward force as a spherical bubble, if the volume is the same.
 
  • #13
stewartcs said:
I can't type that fast Andy! :smile:

Years mis-spent on chat rooms :)
 
  • #14
Andy Resnick said:
The bouyancy force is simply [tex]\Delta mg[/tex]. For a rigid body, regardless of how the mass is distributed in space, the force will be the same. An exceedingly thin (rigid) bubble-sheet-thing will have the same upward force as a spherical bubble, if the volume is the same.

That's what I would have expected... But does the concept of pressure difference between top and bottom still hold?
 
  • #15
Yes, it does. Don't let "exceedingly thin" fool you - it still has a thickness and there is still a pressure difference.
 
  • #16
Domenicaccio said:
That's what I would have expected... But does the concept of pressure difference between top and bottom still hold?

Pressure jumps across an interface can manifest themselves in different ways. Let's consider a neutrally bouyant volume of oil in water (or oil in a water-alcohol bath such that the density is matched). No matter what shape the oil is deformed into, it is still neutrally bouyant and there is no unbalanced force. However, the oil-water interface, being curved, is still associated with a pressure jump. The equilibrium shape of the oil drop is governed by the Laplace equation:

[tex]\Delta P = -\sigma\kappa[/tex],

Where [tex]\sigma[/tex] is the interfacial tension and [tex]\kappa[/tex] the interface curvature. If the oil is not neutrally bouyant, the pressure term has an additional component from the density difference (something like [tex]\Delta P =-\sigma\kappa + \Delta mg A[/tex].. it's too early in the morning to write it down properly)

So our oil drop will assume a different equilbrium shape in the presence of gravity- the surface curvature will change to balance the gravitational component. In liquid bridges, the typical shape in an 'amphora":

http://www.ulb.ac.be/polytech/mrc/research_en.html (near the bottom)

Rigid bodies don't deform, so there is no balancing act between shape and bouyancy. Instead, there is simply an unbalanced force (P = F/Area), which results in motion.
 
  • #17
I am more puzzled now...

If you manage to get a body that has exactly the same density as water, and therefore the weight of the water displaced is equal to the body's weight, according to Archimede's principle this body should float and neither fall or rise, right?

But the body being extended in 3D, there is still a pressure difference from bottom to top. Doesn't this suggest it should move? Or does it just compensate for the gravity?
 
  • #18
Domenicaccio said:
If you manage to get a body that has exactly the same density as water, and therefore the weight of the water displaced is equal to the body's weight, according to Archimede's principle this body should float and neither fall or rise, right?
Yes.
But the body being extended in 3D, there is still a pressure difference from bottom to top. Doesn't this suggest it should move? Or does it just compensate for the gravity?
It just compensates for gravity. Think about water itself, without an object placed in it - pressure varies with depth. Put a bubble aound some water and nothing changes: pressure still varies with depth.
 
  • #19
Another way to picture it is that a neutrally bouyant fluid will assume the shape of a sphere- not only given two immiscible fluids, but also blobs of fluid floating around the Space Station. The curvature is constant over the entire surface, thus the pressure jump across the surface is constant over the entire surface, so there are no unbalanced forces.

Although the 'absolute' pressure varies in height, the pressure *jump* across the interface does not vary.
 

1. What is buoyancy?

Buoyancy is the upward force that a fluid exerts on an object immersed in it. It is caused by the difference in pressure between the top and bottom of the object.

2. How does buoyancy work?

When an object is placed in a fluid, it displaces a certain amount of fluid based on its volume. This displaced fluid exerts an upward force on the object, which is equal to the weight of the displaced fluid. This force is what we call buoyancy.

3. What factors affect buoyancy?

The buoyancy force is affected by the density of the fluid, the volume of the object, and the gravitational force acting on the object. The more dense the fluid, the greater the buoyancy force. Similarly, the larger the volume of the object, the greater the buoyancy force. And if the gravitational force is greater than the buoyancy force, the object will sink.

4. How can we calculate buoyancy?

The buoyancy force can be calculated using Archimedes' principle, which states that the buoyant force is equal to the weight of the fluid that the object displaces. This can be represented by the equation FB = ρVg, where ρ is the density of the fluid, V is the volume of the displaced fluid, and g is the gravitational acceleration.

5. How does buoyancy relate to objects floating or sinking?

If the buoyancy force is greater than the weight of the object, the object will float. If the buoyancy force is less than the weight of the object, the object will sink. And if the buoyancy force is equal to the weight of the object, the object will be neutrally buoyant and will neither float nor sink.

Similar threads

Replies
48
Views
8K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
23
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
34
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
2
Views
5K
Replies
17
Views
669
Back
Top