(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); 1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

[tex] \nabla \times f \vec{v} = f (\nabla \times \vec{v}) + ( \nabla f) \times \vec{v} [/tex]

Use with Stoke's theorem

[tex] \oint _C \vec{A} . \vec{dr} = \int \int _S (\nabla \times \vec{A}) . \vec{dS} [/tex]

to show that

[tex] \oint _c f \vec{dr} = \int \int _S \vec{dS} \times \nabla f[/tex]

2. Relevant equations

I think the only that you really need to know is the the scalar triple product.

3. The attempt at a solution

Ok, I allowed

[tex] \vec{A} = f \vec{v} [/tex]

And subsituted into Stokes' theorem

[tex] \oint _C f\vec{v} . \vec{dr} = \int \int _S (\nabla \times f \vec{v}) . \vec{dS} [/tex]

which gives

[tex] \oint _C f\vec{v} . \vec{dr} = \int \int _S f ((\nabla \times \vec{v}) + ( \nabla f) \times \vec{v} ). \vec{dS} [/tex]

My problem is that I got to this stage, and thought that this would work really great if

[tex] \nabla \times \vec{v} = 0 [/tex].

So I got stuck on this for a while, looked at my textbook, and they said that we let

[tex] \vec{A} = f \vec{v} [/tex] where [tex] \vec{v} [/tex] is aCONSTANT VECTOR.

Hence, the curl of a constant vector is zero, and the RHS becomes

[tex] \int \int _S f ( \nabla f) \times \vec{v} ). \vec{dS} [/tex]

which we rearrange with the triple scalar product identity to give

[tex] \int \int _S f ( \vec{dS} \times \nabla f) ) .\vec{v} [/tex]

So now the thing looks like this:

[tex] \oint _C f\vec{v} . \vec{dr} = \int \int _S f ( \vec{dS} \times \nabla f) ) .\vec{v}

[/tex]

and cancelling [tex] \vec{v} [/tex] from both sides as it's constant, gives us:

[tex] \oint _c f \vec{dr} = \int \int _S \vec{dS} \times \nabla f[/tex]

The problem

My problem is that this restricts the kind of vector field [tex] \vec{A} [/tex] can be, as it has to be a product of some function times a constant vector.

Does this make the derived identity non-universal, or is this a necessary step in order to arrive at the identity?

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Dismiss Notice

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Homework Help: Related to stokes theorem

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**