- #1

tfast

## Main Question or Discussion Point

Hi--

I'm just trying to clean out some physics cobwebs in my head, as I was never much up on relativity; thanks in advance for accomodating me. Here's my question:

Imagine two spacecraft widely separated, but travelling toward each other at significant fractions of c (observed relative to the same reference object, say a sun). What would observers on each spacecraft see in the following situations:

a) each ship travels at v < 0.5c relative to the reference object

b) each ship travels at v = 0.5c relative to the reference object

c) each ship travels at v > 0.5c relative to the reference object

My naive assumption in the case of (a) would be that observers on either ship would see the other ship approaching at 2(v), with light from the other ship blue-shifted in proportion to that speed. However, this doesn't seem to take into account dilation effects, so I'm not really sure of this answer.

So, is the answer above correct, and furthermore, what happens when the ships' relative velocities sum to >= c in cases (b) and (c)? Finally, does anything change when the ships approach one another with velocities different from one other?

Thanks!

I'm just trying to clean out some physics cobwebs in my head, as I was never much up on relativity; thanks in advance for accomodating me. Here's my question:

Imagine two spacecraft widely separated, but travelling toward each other at significant fractions of c (observed relative to the same reference object, say a sun). What would observers on each spacecraft see in the following situations:

a) each ship travels at v < 0.5c relative to the reference object

b) each ship travels at v = 0.5c relative to the reference object

c) each ship travels at v > 0.5c relative to the reference object

My naive assumption in the case of (a) would be that observers on either ship would see the other ship approaching at 2(v), with light from the other ship blue-shifted in proportion to that speed. However, this doesn't seem to take into account dilation effects, so I'm not really sure of this answer.

So, is the answer above correct, and furthermore, what happens when the ships' relative velocities sum to >= c in cases (b) and (c)? Finally, does anything change when the ships approach one another with velocities different from one other?

Thanks!