Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: Relatively open, closed, disconnection

  1. Jun 13, 2007 #1
    The problem has 2 parts. For the first part, I've got a solution that I'd like to confirm. I'm stuck on the second part.

    1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

    PART 1
    Show that if (A,B) is a disconnection of S, then A and B are both relatively open and relatively closed in S.

    PART 2
    Show that if A is a proper subset of S and A is both relatively open and relatively closed, then (A, A-S) is a disconnection of S.

    In essence, show that A ∩ closure(S-A) = Ø and closure(A) ∩ S-A = Ø
    and that A, A-S ≠ Ø

    2. Relevant equations

    Relatively open: A is relatively open in S if there exists an open set U in R^n s.t.
    U ∩ Rn = A

    (A,B) disconnection implies A ∩ closure(B) = Ø and closure(A) ∩ B = Ø

    3. The attempt at a solution

    PART 1
    1) Show that A is relatively open in S:
    closure(B) is closed, so closure(B)c is open.
    Choose U = closure(B)c
    Show this set intersected with S equals A.
    Well, S = A U B and closure(B) ∩ A = Ø
    Thus all the points that are not in closure(B) are in A, so closure(B)c = A
    And S ∩ U = S ∩ closure(B)c = S ∩ A = A
    Thus, A is relatively open in B.
    2) by the same procedure, show that B is relatively open in S
    3) A, B are both relatively open in S. But A ∩ closure(B) = Ø so if A is relatively open, B is relatively closed. And since closure(A) ∩ B = Ø A is relatively closed. Therefore A and B are both relatively open and relatively closed in S.

    PART 2

    A ≠ S and A ≠ Ø, so S-A ≠ S and S-A ≠ Ø
    We know A U S- A = S.

    A is relatively open in S.
    This implies that there exists some open set U in Rn s.t. S ∩ U = A

    Let this set U be closure(S-A)c. We know this is open because closure(S-A) is closed by definition.

    We want to show that U = A. We see this because

    I'm not sure how to bring up the intersection of the closure of A with S-A.

    That's everything for now. Thanks for your help! =)
    Last edited: Jun 13, 2007
  2. jcsd
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Can you offer guidance or do you also need help?
Draft saved Draft deleted