# Riemann Integrable

Is it possible to show by induction that f:[a,b]->R, a bounded function, is Riemann integrable if f has a countable number of discontinuities? I'm told this is usually done with Lebesgue integrals, but I don't see why an inductive proof of this using Riemann/Darboux integrals can't work.

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org
matt grime
Homework Helper
What are you inducting on? It can't be the unmber of discontinuities. showing something for a finite number of things in no way says anything about the infinite case.

NateTG
Homework Helper
Is it possible to show by induction that f:[a,b]->R, a bounded function, is Riemann integrable if f has a countable number of discontinuities? I'm told this is usually done with Lebesgue integrals, but I don't see why an inductive proof of this using Riemann/Darboux integrals can't work.
No.

Consider, for example, the characteristic function of the irrationals.
f(x) is 1 if x is irrational, and 0 if x is rational.

This has a countable number of discontinuities -- one at every rational number -- but is most certainly not Riemann integrable as the lower sum will always be 0, and the upper sum will always be 1.

Last edited:
matt grime
Homework Helper
A 'rational' number of discontinuities? No, it has an uncountable number of discontinuities. It is discontinuous at every point at of the interval [0,1]

Well, f is integrable if it has 1 discontinuity, and whenever it has n discontinuities and is integrable, it implies that having n+1 discontinuities is integrable.

matt grime
Homework Helper
and that tells you nothing (as given) about countably (but not finitely) many discontinuities. (Proof... well, according to this logic, the set of natural numbers is finite by 'induction')

What's wrong with it?

matt grime