Second type perpetual motion machine is existent .

  • Thread starter jaczbcmb
  • Start date
1
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

second type perpetual motion machine is existent .
miaobo

Let us assume that a system make a circulate of thermodynamics ,if we can approve that entropy will not equal to 0 , so the second law of thermodynamics is wrong ,and the second type perpetual motion machine is existent .

The entropy will be changed as the change of temperature of liquid
We assume a experiment : a round glass contain with mercury ,there is a glass tube inserted in the top of glass contain erect .
1. first we assume that the temperature of the system is 20℃
2. the temperature of system move up to 30℃,so mercury entry glass tube ,then the gravitational potential energy of mercury will be increased .these energy is come from outside ,so the system will get more heat quantity .
3. then we turn the glass contain to set glass tube level, so the gravitational potential energy will send out energy .
4. then we let the temperature down to 20℃,whole mercury will back contain ,the system will send out heat quantity Q2 ,but Q2 <Q1 ,if we compare the step with the second step.
5. turn the contain to erect glass tube .
since the potential energy before and after experiment is equal .
DS=dQ1/T-dQ2/T
we can know DS is not equal 0 .
So the entropy and the second lay of thermodynamics are not right
 

Answers and Replies

russ_watters
Mentor
19,016
5,168
Your English is pretty poor, but it looks like you are saying that you get more energy back from a system than you put into it. Sorry, but you won't. It looks like your error is in step 4: when the temperature drops from 30 to 20F, you don't get any potential energy back because the system is already horizontal and you've already recovered the PE.
 
ZapperZ
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
2018 Award
35,216
4,035
Dear PF member,

The thread is locked because it contains opinions that are contrary to those currently held by the scientific community. This is against the Posting Guidelines of Physics Forums. If you would like to discuss your ideas, we invite you to submit a post to the Independent Research Forum, subject to the applicable guidelines, found here.

We appreciate your cooperation, and hope you enjoy the Forums.

Best regards,

The Staff of Physics Forums
 

Related Threads for: Second type perpetual motion machine is existent .

  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
740
Replies
1
Views
204
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
985
Replies
62
Views
18K
Replies
35
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Top