Shape of black holes

  • Thread starter jlroitman
  • Start date
2
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

I am interested in the theoretical shape(s) of black holes. I read that they may be cone shaped, they made be "shells", they may be two dimensional, etc. Can i get some clarification?
thanks, jlr
 

Answers and Replies

Surely if they are a true singularity it doesn't have a shape as it has no real physical dimensions. I would have thought that if anything it would be a sphere, certainly the event horizon is spherical as far as I am aware.
 
Chronos
Science Advisor
Gold Member
11,398
738
Spherical, in the classical sense, seems reasonable. Think horizon.
 
xantox
Gold Member
247
0
I am interested in the theoretical shape(s) of black holes.
By "shape of a black hole" we should mean its event horizon topology.

By Hawking's theorem, all stationary black holes in general relativistic 4D flat spacetime must have a 2-sphere topology. However, black holes in higher dimensional spacetimes may be nonspherical, an example is the Emparan-Reall black hole in 5D flat spacetime which is a [tex]S^1 \times S^2[/tex] ring.
 
Last edited:
marcus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
24,712
783
I am interested in the theoretical shape(s) of black holes. I read that they may be cone shaped, they made be "shells", they may be two dimensional, etc. Can i get some clarification?
thanks, jlr
There is no scientific reason to suppose that singularities exist in nature. A singularity is a place where some manmade theory breaks down and gives meaningless results, like infinities. So singularities exist in theoretical models.

Typically improved models eliminate them, and this has been happening in the case of cosmological and blackhole singularties. As the model is improved one expects to get rid of the glitches, i.e. the singularities.

So your question is about theoretical shapes, shapes in some not necessarily realistic idealization. Fair enough.

The horizon of a nonrotating blackhole is spherical.
The horizon of a rotating blackhole is NOT SPHERICAL. It is an oblate ellipsoid (roundish but fat around the middle.)

Typically what what people mean by the "singularity" is the place where classcial vintage 1915 General Relativity blows up. In the nonrotating case this is a point, and in the rotating case I am told it is a RING. If I'm wrong I hope someone will correct me about this. I'm talking ordinary 3+1 dimensions here, no extra dimensions.

In any case one shouldn't worry too much about the singularities look like because they are not considered real. We don't expect nature to exactly conform to 1915 classic GR! :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
xantox
Gold Member
247
0
The horizon of a rotating blackhole is NOT SPHERICAL. It is an oblate ellipsoid (roundish but fat around the middle.)
No, this is the ergosphere. The Kerr black hole event horizon is spherical.
 
1,986
5
2
0
All very interesting. why, may i ask does the event horizon define this theoretical shape? is the "rest of the black hole" a non-entity? or is it the singularity that is referred to above. i thought that the black hole culminated in the singularity. does all this mean that the black hole consists of (theoretically, of course) an event horizon that may or may not be spherical and a singularity and nothing else in-between?
 
xantox
Gold Member
247
0
The event horizon is relevant, since the black hole is basically an entity made of space. So, you may look at the geometry of this very particular space in order to talk about a shape.

About the "rest of the black hole", this depends on the theory used to describe it. In the classical theory, the interior details cannot determine the exterior description. In quantum theory, singularities tend to disappear.

Physical black holes cannot be empty "in-between", even in classical general relativity, as if you throw things into them, they will for some time exist "in-between".
 
Last edited:

Related Threads for: Shape of black holes

Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
691
  • Last Post
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
16
Views
5K
  • Last Post
5
Replies
119
Views
12K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
39
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
2K
Top