Shortcircuiting a pn diode

  • Thread starter Tsunami
  • Start date
92
0
A thought experiment: (note that this comes from a student with only amateur experience in solid state physics)

suppose you could shortcircuit a pn diode... ie you just link a wire between both ends, or maybe even bend the pn diode in a ring (so you'd have a n-surface between two p-surfaces, and a p-surface between two n-surfaces).

What would you get?

Based on that second idea, I was thinking something among the lines of : you'd get two depletion areas at both ends, with a width that's equal to half of the width you'd get from a single end connection.


I'm having problems with realizing what the differences in characteristics are between the 'internal potential' of the diode, evoked by the difference in free electron concentration (I hope that's an ok interpretation) , and the 'external potential', evoked by the source. I understand how the external potential can 'amplify' or 'lessen' the diode effect - that's somewhat like simple charge induction - however, when I try to combine the idea of the diode and the external potential as in above experiment, I get stuck. Maybe it would help if someone showed me convincingly why a diode can't be used as a power source.
 

ZapperZ

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
2018 Award
35,114
3,922
Tsunami said:
A thought experiment: (note that this comes from a student with only amateur experience in solid state physics)

suppose you could shortcircuit a pn diode... ie you just link a wire between both ends, or maybe even bend the pn diode in a ring (so you'd have a n-surface between two p-surfaces, and a p-surface between two n-surfaces).

What would you get?
You may want to look into what a solid-state transistor is. These are either npn or pnp junctions.

Zz.
 
92
0
A transistor is not really the same as shortcircuiting a diode I think..
 

Integral

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
7,185
55
There is little if any free charges in a semiconductor. Short circiuting a diode by itself will do nothing.
 
3,761
8
Tsunami said:
A thought experiment: (note that this comes from a student with only amateur experience in solid state physics)

suppose you could shortcircuit a pn diode... ie you just link a wire between both ends, or maybe even bend the pn diode in a ring (so you'd have a n-surface between two p-surfaces, and a p-surface between two n-surfaces).

What would you get?

Based on that second idea, I was thinking something among the lines of : you'd get two depletion areas at both ends, with a width that's equal to half of the width you'd get from a single end connection.


I'm having problems with realizing what the differences in characteristics are between the 'internal potential' of the diode, evoked by the difference in free electron concentration (I hope that's an ok interpretation) , and the 'external potential', evoked by the source. I understand how the external potential can 'amplify' or 'lessen' the diode effect - that's somewhat like simple charge induction - however, when I try to combine the idea of the diode and the external potential as in above experiment, I get stuck. Maybe it would help if someone showed me convincingly why a diode can't be used as a power source.
if you had come up with this idea like 40/50 years back, you would have the same financial capacity like Bill Gates.

Google for MOSFET or look at my latest entries in my journal. In the very last one i explain (briefly) two of the three stages of MOSFET operation : ie accumulation, depletion and inversion

regards
marlon
 
137
0
Maybe it would help if someone showed me convincingly why a diode can't be used as a power source.
Actually a diode can be used as a power source if you drive it out of equilibrium by an external light source. On the other hand, no power can be generated by any device in equilibrium- it should obey to the first and second law of thermodynamics.
 
92
0
marlon said:
if you had come up with this idea like 40/50 years back, you would have the same financial capacity like Bill Gates.

Google for MOSFET or look at my latest entries in my journal. In the very last one i explain (briefly) two of the three stages of MOSFET operation : ie accumulation, depletion and inversion

regards
marlon
Thank you very much - but I have to give the credit to a guy from my class. He came up with the original idea, I simply came up with the ring experiment.

(And I'll be sure to read your journal as soon as I have the time... my vacation seems to be more hectic than the rest of the year.)
 

Related Threads for: Shortcircuiting a pn diode

  • Posted
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
475
  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
896
  • Posted
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
963
  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
456

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top