1. Nov 14, 2005

### kevin86

This is pretty simple, just give me a quick concept should be enough, no need to go over the details.

What determines the radius size again? Was it just the electrons?

Say for example which is bigger, potassium ion or argon. Same electron configuration but different proton numbers. Would the extra proton pull the electrons to make it smaller for potassium or would the extra proton make the radius bigger. This isnt homework or anything, use another example if you want.

2. Nov 14, 2005

### bomba923

Here are some of the factors:

1) Atomic number
2) Electron shielding
3) Relative orbital ranks

Potassium cation has the same electron configuration as argon. (i.e., $$1s^2 2s^2 2p^6 3s^2 3p^6$$).
The extra proton found within the potassium nucleus will, in effect, produce a stronger nuclear charge (positive) to attract each electron. Relatively speaking, argon will have a weaker nuclear charge due to a smaller proton quantity (since 18 < 19).

Therefore, the valence electrons of potassium cation will be held closer to the nucleus than the valence electrons of argon.

Therefore, potassium cation will have a smaller atomic radius than argon.

(In your question, you simply end up comparing atomic numbers.)

Last edited: Nov 14, 2005
3. Nov 14, 2005

### kevin86

thanks, that was very insightful.