Simple question about work and friction

In summary, work is defined as the product of the force applied and the distance the object moves in the direction of the force. In situations where there are balanced forces acting on an object, no work is done as there is no change in motion. In the case of friction, work is only done when there is motion between the surfaces. The concept of work is important in understanding the transfer of energy to an object.
  • #1
elvinc
10
0
Hi,
The simple definition of work done by a constant force on moving a constant mass is

(size of) force on object multiplied by (size of) distance object moves in direction of force while force is applied

In the ideal case of a puck on frictionless ice, an applied constant force will cause the puck to accelerate as long as the force is applied. The work done by the force on the puck transfers energy to the puck in the form of kinetic energy.

Ok – I understand that.

Take two scenarios of 1) pushing the puck on a rough surface and 2) lifting an object against gravity

In both case two balanced forces are acting on the object and the object (ideally) does not accelerate

Situation 1) the two forces acting on the puck are the pushing force and the friction. So which force is doing work on the block? Why, when we calculate the work done on the block do we use one force (say the pushing force) and ignore the other (friction)? Could we not argue that as the resultant force is zero then no work is done on the block? That won't work (pun intended) because we can't explain where the heat been the rubbed surfaces comes from.

Situation 2) is pretty much the same. We lift the object vertically against gravitational attraction of the earth. If the block does not accelerate the weight and lifting force are balanced and opposite. If the object is placed on a shelf at a height above the floor then it has gravitational potential energy so work must have been done on the block. Again how do we calculate the work done? Do we just multiply the lifting force by distance moved and ignore the weight? Yes, probably, but why?

Thanks

Clive
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
elvinc said:
Hi,
The simple definition of work done by a constant force on moving a constant mass is

(size of) force on object multiplied by (size of) distance object moves in direction of force while force is applied

In the ideal case of a puck on frictionless ice, an applied constant force will cause the puck to accelerate as long as the force is applied. The work done by the force on the puck transfers energy to the puck in the form of kinetic energy.

Ok – I understand that.

Take two scenarios of 1) pushing the puck on a rough surface and 2) lifting an object against gravity

In both case two balanced forces are acting on the object and the object (ideally) does not accelerate

Situation 1) the two forces acting on the puck are the pushing force and the friction. So which force is doing work on the block? Why, when we calculate the work done on the block do we use one force (say the pushing force) and ignore the other (friction)? Could we not argue that as the resultant force is zero then no work is done on the block? That won't work (pun intended) because we can't explain where the heat been the rubbed surfaces comes from.

Situation 2) is pretty much the same. We lift the object vertically against gravitational attraction of the earth. If the block does not accelerate the weight and lifting force are balanced and opposite. If the object is placed on a shelf at a height above the floor then it has gravitational potential energy so work must have been done on the block. Again how do we calculate the work done? Do we just multiply the lifting force by distance moved and ignore the weight? Yes, probably, but why?

Thanks

Clive

In the two cases you quote, only one of each the two forces is acting in the direction of motion of the object.
 
  • #3
Your problem is that you do not get the concept of work. Like you said, to get work, i.e. energy spent, you need a force and movement. If there is no motion there is no work done like the example of the book sitting on a shelf.

But to get the book on the shelf from, say, the floor, you need to spend energy which will be equal to weight of the book (the lifting force) times the distance between the shelf and the floor.

Similarly for the friction case, if there is no motion, there is no friction, hence no energy spent, no work done. As soon as the object moves, friction starts and the work done is equal to the friction force times the distance traveled.

For your puck on frictionless ice, you will input a force (= ma) for a certain distance (x) at which point the puck will have acquire a certain speed (v² = 2ax). At this point, if you remove the force, the puck will go at the acquired speed forever. In this case you have motion but no force, so there is no work done.
 
  • #4
if there is no motion, there is no friction

Static friction?

Your other statements are OK.
 
  • #5
Studiot said:
Static friction?

I was more thinking in terms of an horizontal plane but if the plane is incline, you're right, up to a certain angle, there will be static friction that will hold the object in place. Still, there is a force but no motion ---> no work done.
 
  • #6
Static friction applies whatever the inclination.
An object is held in place against a displacing force by until the force exceeds the static friction. Clearly no work is done until the object moves but the static friction force is always present.
 

1. What is friction?

Friction is a force that resists the motion of objects when they come into contact with each other.

2. How does friction affect work?

Friction can make it more difficult to do work because it creates a resistance or opposing force against the motion of an object.

3. Can friction be helpful in doing work?

Yes, friction can be helpful in certain situations. For example, friction allows us to walk without slipping and helps vehicles stop by creating a braking force.

4. What factors affect the amount of friction?

The amount of friction between two objects can be affected by the types of surfaces in contact, the force pushing them together, and the roughness of the surfaces.

5. How can we reduce friction in order to make work easier?

There are a few ways to reduce friction, such as using lubricants, making surfaces smoother, or using wheels or rollers to minimize contact between objects. Reducing friction can make it easier to do work by decreasing the resistance or opposing force.

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
977
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
34
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
745
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
514
Back
Top