Slowing gravity?

  • Thread starter Zefram
  • Start date
55
0
Gravity is supposed to propogate at the speed of light; but is there any way to slow it down "in a medium" as light can be? Are gravitons (theoretically) supposed to be emitted and absorbed by masses the way photons are by atoms? If so, could something like a star cluster act in the same way a medium does for light to "slow down" gravity (i.e. take a gravitational signal, with all the absorbing and reemitting, longer to travel from one side of the cluster to the other than if no masses were present)? Or am I completely off here?
 

LURCH

Science Advisor
2,546
117
One of the predicted properties of gravity waves is that they are not interfered with by passing through obstructions between the source and the observer. This is one of the many reasons why astronomers are so keen on developing ways to detect them. If this property proves true, then it would seem to suggest that the waves cannot be "red-shifted", slowed, or weakend by any medium. This is only my reasoning on the matter, and there may be more reliable information at MIT's LIGO Website .

Although this does raise the question of whether or not they can be interfered with by other gravity waves. Never thought of the idea of gravity wave interferometry before, but I'm sure I'm not the first. Must go search.
 
55
0
This is a point I'm not clear on: are gravity waves the same things as gravitons? I know there are projects like LIGO and VIRGO (and maybe LISA someday) to detect gravity waves directly (and that Nobel prize from ten years ago that involved the indirect detection of them) but when a gravity wave is definitely detected will that be the same as saying gravitons have been detected? I've seen people refer to them as if they're the same but they sound like two different things to me.

But, regardless, are gravitons emitted and absorbed by masses in any way analogous to the way photons are?
 

Janus

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
3,398
1,075
Originally posted by Zefram
This is a point I'm not clear on: are gravity waves the same things as gravitons? I know there are projects like LIGO and VIRGO (and maybe LISA someday) to detect gravity waves directly (and that Nobel prize from ten years ago that involved the indirect detection of them) but when a gravity wave is definitely detected will that be the same as saying gravitons have been detected? I've seen people refer to them as if they're the same but they sound like two different things to me.

But, regardless, are gravitons emitted and absorbed by masses in any way analogous to the way photons are?
Gravitons and gravity waves bear the same relationship to each other as photons and electromagnetic waves do. They are the quantum and classical representation of the same thing.

I think what gets confusing is when people refer to the graviton as the force-carrying particle for gravity.

This is not strictly true. The force carrying particle for gravity would be the virtual graviton. In the same way, virtual photons mediate the electromagnetic force.

so it goes like this:

for light
wave: electromagnetic
particle : photon
Field: electromagnetic
Force carrier : virtual photon

for gravity
wave: Gravity
particle: graviton
Field: Gravitational
force carrier: virtual graviton

In classical terms one usually refers to waves and fields, in quantum terms, particles and virtual particles.
 
499
1
I don't think gravity waves could be slowed down. Gravity waves by their nature would be propogations of a space/time wave. Much like light does not require a medium to move in, but particles will make it slow down, since gravity is the very essence of a spacetime disturbance, one would have to put the wave in something other than spacetime...but if you can find one of those, I'll give you an infinite amount of money.
 
55
0
All right, thanks for the responses. Too bad to hear there's no gravitational analogue of Cherenkov radiation.
 
499
1
There wouldn't be unless, as I stated, you managed to make a gravity wave move in something other than spacetime. And as I stated, if you do, please by all means contact me. You'll get an infinite amount of money hehe.
 
196
0
Light is slowed down by gravity, and I can think of nothing that can slow down gravity...
 

Related Threads for: Slowing gravity?

Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
4
Views
2K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top