• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products via PF Here!

Special Relativity: Find the reference frame in which two events are Simultaneous

  • Thread starter khfrekek92
  • Start date
1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
events A(ct,x)=(1m, 2m) and B(ct,x)=(3m,4m) are separated in a lightlike interval. I need to find the velocity of a seperate reference frame in which they BOTH occur at the same time.

Next I need to find the velocity of the frame where they will occur at the same LOCATION.

2. Relevant equations
t=(gamme)t'


3. The attempt at a solution
To solve for this, I need to find where the t' for both events is equal. But when i set tb'=ta', everything cancels out and I end up getting 1=3. Is there any other way of doing this that I am missing? I am getting the same problem with the location part as well.

Thanks in advance!
 
Or am I just doing this completely wrong?
 

Nugatory

Mentor
12,119
4,600
This problem appears to have been designed to force you to think about the physical situation it describes before you jump into the equations and formulas. Think about why we use the word "lightlike" to describe some intervals.
 
Hmmm... Well Lightlike means they are only in a causal relationship if you use light. So would the frame of reference have to moving at speed c? I thought you can't have a frame moving at speed c?
 
260
1
Hmmm... Well Lightlike means they are only in a causal relationship if you use light. So would the frame of reference have to moving at speed c? I thought you can't have a frame moving at speed c?
That's a bingo!
 
Oh! Duh, why didn't I think of that? So if they were in a spacelike interval, you still wouldn't be able to have them happen at the same time, would you?
 

Nugatory

Mentor
12,119
4,600
Hmmm... Well Lightlike means they are only in a causal relationship if you use light. So would the frame of reference have to moving at speed c? I thought you can't have a frame moving at speed c?
A better description of lightlike separation might be that a flash of light could have been emitted at one event and absorbed at the other... But this definition will bring you to the same result.
 

Matterwave

Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,951
324
Remember that ds^2 is an invariant. This means that if ds^2=0 in one frame, then it is 0 in all frames. Further, this means that ds^2 can never change signs. 2 events which occur at the same time must have ds^2<0 (assuming metric (+ - - -)), and 2 events which occur at the same point in space must have ds^2>0.
 

Nugatory

Mentor
12,119
4,600
Oh! Duh, why didn't I think of that? So if they were in a spacelike interval, you still wouldn't be able to have them happen at the same time, would you?
Either you have it backwards or you're typing too quickly: spacelike separation means that they'll be always be at different locations, but you can find a reference frame in which they happen at the same time or either one before the other.
 
1,860
0
I just did a similar problem, but with runners in a time-like interval. The problem was that two runners were racing, one runner was given a time handicap, find an inertial frame where the handicap doesn't exist. You don't have to going at the speed of light for something to APPEAR to happen at the same time from another frame. The question was pretty open-ended (Jackson...), but I basically said/found that if these are regular human runners you'll have to be going much faster for relativistic effects so just ignore velocity addition (or travel perpendicular to running motion), and there was a definite speed at which an observer in K' claims the runners started at the same time. Just wanted to throw this bit of info at you to add to confusion :p
 
Haha! Thanks so much guys, I finally got all of them done (there was one problem for finding equal times AND distances for each of the three intervals.) Thanks so much for all of your help!

-Zack
 

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top