Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Speed of gravity modification

  1. Nov 12, 2011 #1
    Let's say i state following things:
    1) c decreases in gravitational field (Shapiro delay)
    2) gravity travels at the speed of light
    3) gravity is inner force
    4) black holes do have gravitational effect

    When light approaches event horizon, it's speed approaches 0, and inside black hole light can't escape. So how gravity can? We are in gravitational field, so gravity propagates faster then c by c + delta c where delta c is c change in gravitational field. Any ideas on the insight?
     
    Last edited: Nov 12, 2011
  2. jcsd
  3. Nov 12, 2011 #2

    DrGreg

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    It's only changes in gravity that need to travel. When an event horizon forms, the gravity outside it is already there and will remain there without anything having to travel outwards through the horizon.
     
  4. Nov 13, 2011 #3
    Well yes. But let's ask how fast does the gravity of the sun reaches earth? It's the same time as the light reaches earth. But light in a presence of massive body travels slower (takes longer or distance increase - no matter what interpretation you prefer)
    How gravity can be outside blackhole if gravity is inner force and mass lies inside black hole?
     
    Last edited: Nov 13, 2011
  5. Nov 13, 2011 #4

    DrGreg

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    While the Sun just sits there doing nothing, its gravity doesn't change, so nothing needs to travel from Sun to Earth to maintain the constant gravity. The Sun's gravity is already here on the Earth, and has been here ever since the Sun was formed.

    Suppose the Sun were to suddenly explode and divide into two pieces that shot off at high speed in opposite directions. That change would change the gravity, and it would take 8 minutes for the change in gravity to reach Earth.

    But if gravity is static, nothing changes and nothing needs to travel.

    In the case of a black hole, the gravity around it already existed before the event horizon was formed. This gravity was caused by the mass (or more accurately the stress-energy-momentum) of the material that was collapsing to form the black hole. Nothing happened after that to change the gravity, so the gravity is still there. Nothing needs to travel out of the event horizon to maintain a static gravity.
     
  6. Nov 13, 2011 #5

    Dale

    Staff: Mentor

    If you mean the static gravitational field this is incorrect. The earth is attracted towards the sun's current position, not the retarded position. Otherwise the earth's orbit would not be stable.
     
  7. Nov 13, 2011 #6
    DrGreg, BH mass isn't static. If the light reaches an object at the same time as the gravity reaches object, then what if the light can't reach us? The incorrect assumption would be to say that BH that appeared in observable universe has no gravitational force.


    Another incorrect assumption would be:
    If the light from more massive body takes longer to reach an object, then the gravity does the same, because gravity reaches at the same time as light does. All I'm saying that we see gravity first, and light a little bit later (by shapiro effect), same for gravitational changes.
     
    Last edited: Nov 13, 2011
  8. Nov 13, 2011 #7

    Dale

    Staff: Mentor

    Please show your derivation from the Einstein field equations.
     
  9. Nov 13, 2011 #8

    DrGreg

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Black holes don't just magically appear from nowhere. They occur as a result of matter collapsing. The matter that originally forms a black hole was already there before the event horizon formed, and the gravity due that matter already existed. When the event horizon formed, as far as any distant observer was concerned, there was no change. The gravity before and after was exactly the same. So nothing has to travel outward. The gravity doesn't need to "reach us" if it's already there.

    If the black hole grows, the growth comes from more matter falling in from outside. While this matter is still outside it "increases the gravity", and that increase can propagate at the speed of light to distant objects. Once the matter falls through the event horizon, there is no further change to the gravity so nothing further needs to travel to distant objects.

    I think you misunderstand the Shapiro effect, which says that light travels slower out of a gravitational "hole" than it would if there was no gravity. It says nothing about the speed of changes in gravity, which would be the same speed as any light making the same journey.
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook




Similar Discussions: Speed of gravity modification
  1. Speed of Gravity. (Replies: 2)

  2. The Speed of Gravity (Replies: 15)

  3. Speed of gravity (Replies: 1)

  4. Speed of gravity? (Replies: 28)

Loading...