Spring stretched at both ends

  • Thread starter bgq
  • Start date
  • #1
bgq
160
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

Hi,

Consider a spring of stiffness k and mass m. If we stretch - simultaneously - both ends of the spring by force F1 and F2. What will be the elongation of the spring? Can I add the forces and say that
x = (F1 + F2)/k ?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
1,929
228
Hi,

Consider a spring of stiffness k and mass m. If we stretch - simultaneously - both ends of the spring by force F1 and F2. What will be the elongation of the spring? Can I add the forces and say that
x = (F1 + F2)/k ?
No, you can't add the forces. If the forces are unequal, the spring itself will start to accelarate in the direction of the largest force. F = ma applies here, where F is the net force.

To stretch a spring, you always have to exert a force on both sides. Even if you tie the spring to an unmoveable object, the object will still exert the same force on one side of the spring, as the force on the other side, because the spring now can't move, so the net force on it has to be 0
 
  • #3
bgq
160
0
No, you can't add the forces. If the forces are unequal, the spring itself will start to accelarate in the direction of the largest force. F = ma applies here, where F is the net force.

To stretch a spring, you always have to exert a force on both sides. Even if you tie the spring to an unmoveable object, the object will still exert the same force on one side of the spring, as the force on the other side, because the spring now can't move, so the net force on it has to be 0
If it is at equilibrium so that F1 = F2 = F. Is elongation x = F/k or x = 2F/k?
 
  • #4
AlephZero
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
6,993
291
If it is at equilibrium so that F1 = F2 = F.
When it is in equilibrium, F1 = F and F2 = -F.

Forces are vector quantities, they have magnitude and direction.

Is elongation x = F/k or x = 2F/k?
x = F/k. Adding two forces of magnitude "F" that act in different directions, to get "2F", is meaningless.
 
  • #5
bgq
160
0
The spring may be compressed or elongated even if it is accelerating. My question is how to find the elongation or compression is such a situation.
 
  • #6
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
8,093
2,921
The spring may be compressed or elongated even if it is accelerating. My question is how to find the elongation or compression is such a situation.
Take the average of the tension (or compression) force at the two ends and compute the amount of elongation or compression based on that.

For instance, consider a spring hanging from one end. The tension at the one end is mg. The tension at the other end is zero. So, on average the tension across the length of the spring is mg/2.

Be sure to watch your sign conventions. If a spring is being pushed from the back with a force of 10 Newtons and pulled from the front with a force of 20 newtons, that's 20 minus 10 all divided by 2 for an average tension of 5 Newtons.

You can derive this result by treating the original spring as a bunch of smaller springs connected end-to-end and then adding up the displacements that result from the tension or compression experienced by each of the smaller springs.
 

Related Threads for: Spring stretched at both ends

Replies
8
Views
525
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
22K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
729
Top