• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Stability: Ladder Problem

  • #1
103
5

Homework Statement


image.jpg


Where it says ''from the bottom'' I assumed it's referring to a distance along the ladder. So:


image.jpg


Data:

##w_{ladder} = 98.0\ N##

##w_{person} = 686\ N##

##d_1 = 4\sqrt(2)\ m##

##d_2 = 1\ m##

##d_3 = 2/3\ m##


Homework Equations



##\sum \tau = 0##

##\sum F = 0##

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
Diagram:

image.jpg
image.jpg


I chose my pivot point to be the bottom of the ladder. Hence, torques due to normal force ##N## and friction ##f## are zero. ##ccw## is positive and ##cw## is negative.

##0 = w_pd_2 + w_ld_3 - F_wd_1##

##F_wd_1 = w_pd_2 + w_ld_3##

##F_w = \frac{w_pd_2 + w_ld_3}{d_1} = \frac{686\ N \cdot 1.00\ m + 98.0\ N \cdot 2/3\ m}{4\sqrt{2}\ m} = 133\ N##

##F_w = f = 133\ N##

Then:

##N = w_p + w_l = 686\ N + 98.0\ N = 784\ N##

The force at the top of the ladder is just ##133\ N##.
The force at the bottom is ##\small{\sqrt{N^2+ f^2} = \sqrt{ (784\ N)^2+ (133\ N)^2} = 795\ N}##. Doubt: this magnitude, whether it's correct or not, acts along the ladder, right? (as a tension would?).

The textbook's solutions are ##126\ N## and ##751\ N##, respectively. It seems I haven't missed anything, so I don't know where the mistake is.
 
Last edited:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
BvU
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
13,017
3,009
Which direction does Fw point ?
 
  • #3
103
5
Which direction does Fw point ?
To the right.

And in a cw direction about the pivot point.
 
  • #4
BvU
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
13,017
3,009
No vertical component ?
 
  • #5
103
5
No vertical component ?
Components of ##F_w##? Mmm, It didn't occur to me that there could be vertical components there. Has that of a ''frictionless rain gutter'' something to do with it?
 
  • #6
103
5
It seems that I also forgot to take ##F_w## into account when finding the force at the bottom.
 
  • #7
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
32,722
5,029
Components of ##F_w##? Mmm, It didn't occur to me that there could be vertical components there. Has that of a ''frictionless rain gutter'' something to do with it?
Frictionless says there will only be a normal force. Normal means perpendicular to the surface of contact. What direction will that be? You should assume the ladder projects slightly beyond the point of contact with the gutter.
 
  • #8
BvU
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
13,017
3,009
Components of ##F_w##? Mmm, It didn't occur to me that there could be vertical components there. Has that of a ''frictionless rain gutter'' something to do with it?
Consider a more extreme case where the ladder is at 45 degrees (or even less) wrt the ground. Would it lean ON the gutter, as well as against the gutter ?
 
  • #9
103
5
I think I'm getting the idea. It would be something like this:

gutter.jpg



However I'm not sure what is the correct direction that ##F_w## takes.

I think the sharp corner of the gutter can be viewed as a fulcrum. Should ##F_w## act perpendicular to the edge of the gutter, as bisecting it? If that were the case, my drawing wouldn't be totally accurate. Would it be in that direction, independent of the angle that the ladder makes with the ground?.
 
  • #10
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
32,722
5,029
Should ##F_w## act perpendicular to the edge of the gutter, as bisecting it?
No. It might help to rotate the problem around to a more familiar set-up. Imagine a table on flat level ground, but the legs of the table are sharp wedges, meeting the ground at some odd angle. Which way would the normal force act?
More generally, as I wrote, normal means perpendicular to the contact plane. I'm not sure how contact planes are defined generally, but if either surface is differentiable then it will be the tangent plane which passes through the point of contact. Taking the ladder uprights to be rectangular in section, they have a differentiable surface. Or if you take them to be arbitrarily thin rods then it must be a plane containing that rod and containing the edge line of the gutter - there is only one such. Sounds complicated, but the underlying idea is fairly intuitive.
 
  • #11
BvU
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2019 Award
13,017
3,009
Another approach: ladder pushes against gutter. In which direction ? Gutter pushes back, opposite direction (no friction).

If there were a rubber hose between the two, how would it compress ? To a vertical ellipse ? Or to an ellipse with the long axis parallel to the ladder ?
 
  • #12
103
5
I would say to an ellipse with the long axis parallel to the ladder, which would mean that the force exerted by the gutter on the ladder is perpendicular to it.

In the other case (leaning against a wall), the wall becomes the differentiable surface and the rubber hose would compress parallel to it. It makes sense.

If the gutter weren't frictionless, friction would act parallel to the ladder's structure, right?
 
  • #13
haruspex
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
32,722
5,029
I would say to an ellipse with the long axis parallel to the ladder, which would mean that the force exerted by the gutter on the ladder is perpendicular to it.

In the other case (leaning against a wall), the wall becomes the differentiable surface and the rubber hose would compress parallel to it. It makes sense.

If the gutter weren't frictionless, friction would act parallel to the ladder's structure, right?
Yes, I agree with all of that.
 

Related Threads on Stability: Ladder Problem

  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
14K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
9K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
8K
Replies
10
Views
680
Replies
5
Views
755
Top