Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: Statistical Probability Distributions

  1. Nov 30, 2004 #1
    I have two questions, I've completed. I am partially sure that the answers I've obtained are correct, and all I really want is confirmation on whether they are correct or not. If not, what am I doing wrong?

    Question 1:

    If the joint probability distribution of X1 and X2 is given by:

    F(X1,X2) = (X1X2)/36

    Where X1 = 1,2,3, and X2 = 1,2,3

    a) Find the probability distribution of X1X2.


    Y = X1X2
    X2 = Y/X1
    dX2/dY = 1/X1

    g(X1,Y) = [X1(Y/X1)/36][|1/X1|] = Y/36X1, For X1=1,2,3, and Y>0

    Therefore, h(y) = Integral from 1 to 3: (Y/36X1)dX1 = Yln3/36, for Y>0

    h(y) = 0, elsewhere.

    b) Find the probability distribution of X1/X2


    Y = X1/X2
    X2 = X1/Y
    dX2/dY = -X1/Y^2

    g(X1,Y) = [[X1(X1/Y)]/36][|-X1/Y^2|] = X1^3/36Y^3, For X1 = 1,2,3, and Y>0

    Therefore, h(Y) = Integral from 1 to 3: (X1^3/36Y^3)dX1 = 5/9Y^3, for Y>0

    h(y) = 0, elsewhere

    Question 2:

    Consider two random variables X and Y with the joint probability density:

    f(X,Y) = {12XY(1-Y), for 0<X<1, 0<y<1.
    0, elsewhere

    Find the probability density of Z=XY^2 to determine the joint probability density of Y and Z and then integrating out Y.


    Z = XY^2
    X = Z/Y^2
    dX/dZ = 1/Y^2

    g(Y,Z) = 12(Z/Y^2)(Y)(|1/Y^2|) = 12Z/Y^3, for 0<Y<1, and 0<Z<1

    h(y) = Integral from 0 to 1: (12Z/Y^3)dy = Infinity, does not exist.


    References: Functions of Random Variables - Transformation Technique of Several Variables.

    Thanks in advance. I appreciate it.
    Last edited: Nov 30, 2004
  2. jcsd
  3. Dec 1, 2004 #2


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    These are discrete variables, why do you integrate?

    Make tables for probabilities P(X1=i, X2=j) for i, j = 1, 2, 3. For example, P(X1=2, X2=3)=(2*3)/36 = 1/6. You get the same probability when X1=3 and X2=2: P(X1=3, X2=2)=1/6.

    Now find the possible values for X1*X2, and the possible values of both X1 and X2 which yield that product.

    X1*X2 can have the value of 6 either with X1=2 and X2=3 or with X1=3 and X2=2.

    So P(X1X2=6)=P(2,3)+P(3,2)=2*1/6=1/3.

    Try to proceed this way.

  4. Dec 1, 2004 #3
    You're right, that was a careless mistake.

    I've corrected it now.

    Instead of integration for Part a)

    It should now read:


    h(y) = Sigma from X1=1 to 3: (Y/36X1) = Y/36+Y/72+Y/108 = 11Y/216, Y>0
    h(y) = 0, elsewhere.


    h(y) = Sigma from X1=1 to 3: (X1^3/36Y^3) = (1^3+2^3+3^3)/36Y^3
    = 36/36Y^3 = 1/Y^3, Y>0
    h(y) = 0, elsewhere.

    So how about now? Any other errors?

    Also, what about the second question? Doesn't it strike you as odd that the answer is infinity?...
  5. Dec 2, 2004 #4


    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    I am afraid you did it entirely wrong. The sum of h(Y)-s for all possible values of x1*x2 which are 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, must be 1. You can check yourself if your values meet this requirement. They do not.

    You got h(Y)=11Y/216. The sum for all possible Y-s is 25*11/216 instead of 1.

    Now again.

    Y=1 can be only if both X1 and X2 is 1. f(X1,X2)=(X1X2)/36=1/36, so h(1)=1/36.

    Y=2 is possible if either X1=1 and X2=2 or X1=2 and X2=1. f(1,2)=f(2,1)=2/36.
    h(2)=f(1,2)+f(2,1)= 4/36.

    Y=3 is obtained by x1=1 and x2=3 or vice versa. f(1,3)=f(3,1)=3/36, h(3)=6/36.

    Yo get in the same way that h(4)= f(2*2) = 4/36;h(6)=f(2.3)+f(3,2)=12/36; h(9)=f(3,3)=9/36.

    The sum of all h-s is (1+4+6+12+9)/36 =1.

    Continue with question b....

Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook