Hi all.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

I am a PhD student in a condensed matter group.

Consider: I observe superlattice reflections due to ferrimagnetic order that requires one cell parameter to be multiplied by M, the next by N and the third by O .

In other words, the magnetic order is described by a magnetic unit cell that is Ma x Nb x Oc

This leads to (H/M K/N L/O) reflections, where H,K,L are integers.

In order to calculate the structure factor for reflection (H/M K/N L/O) I construct the Ma x Nb x Oc cell and perform the sum:

[tex]F \left( \textbf{Q} \right) = \sum_{i}{f0_{i} \left( \textbf{Q} \right) \exp{ \left( i \textbf{Q} \cdot{} \textbf{r}_{i}\right) } } = \sum_{i}{f0_{i} \left( \textbf{Q} \right) \exp{ \left[ 2\pi i \left( hx + ky + lz\right) \right]} }[/tex]

Over the now much larger basis of atoms.

I divide by the ratio of the volumes in order to compare with any intensity calculated directly from the a x b x c cell (for example to compare with previously calculated nuclear scattering).

To me this is fine. My thesis supervisor is concerned based upon the following:

If you take the Ma x Nb x Oc cell but make it ferromagnetic the satellites become forbidden.

When I calculate F(H K L) corresponding to a non-integer peak I get zero (yay).

However, the non-integer reflection is also forbidden in the original cell, and my supervisor insists that if I substitute non-integer values for H, K and L into the structure factor for the a x b x c cell with its limited basis I should be able to demonstrate it is forbidden.

I believe that the structure factor calculation as done above is only valid for integer H, K and L due to the fundamental relation between the atomic basis and the real space (and reciprocal space) translation vectors.

I have attached something I gave to my supervisor; however, I think it is still unclear as I merely demonstrate a fairly simple example (the symmetry of the real system is much worse than simple cubic!).

If you are still reading and haven't lost interest: can anyone see what I mean and what I SHOULD be saying?

Thanks in advance for anything people can come up with.

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Structure Factor for non-Integer miller indices

Can you offer guidance or do you also need help?

Draft saved
Draft deleted

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**