Can Superconducting Generators Improve Efficiency in Hydropower Plants?

In summary: What is IIRC? I googled it but couldn't get a satisfactory answer.I only know of a single 1.7MW unit HTS generator being made for a hydropower plant in Germany.
  • #1
Tseyrin
12
2
i believe that superconducting generators are now in use,We have hydropower plants in our country still using the conventional generators. My idea for my masters dessertation would to replace these generators with the superconducting ones, and hopefully get better efficiency.
Would this make a good dessertation basis? Or should i go for something else?? Your suggestions would be very welcomed. Thank u
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Superconducting generators are not really that much more efficient than conventional generators (which are already very efficient). The main advantage of SC generators is that they can be much smaller and lighter than a copper generator for the same power rating; this is why they might be very useful in places where there is a limited amount of space; for example on ships. Some companies are also trying to use them for wind turbines.
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #3
Seems thin for a master's thesis. What exactly would you need to investigate that you couldn't do in a weekend?

Also, why limit it to hydro generators?
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #4
yes. It rele wasn't the best idea, i could come up with. I am pressed for time(long story) and i need to come up with a topic and present it the day after.

i wanted to go for a topic related to hydropower because its the only source of power generation in my country. I am from Bhutan. I thought whatever research i do might be actually useful in the future.

is there any other topic that you could suggest?? It would be a great help. Thank you
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
russ_watters said:
Seems thin for a master's thesis. What exactly would you need to investigate that you couldn't do in a weekend?

Also, why limit it to hydro generators?

sir, could please suggest a better topic?? Some thing to do with increasing efficiency in hydropower generation. I need to get this in by Friday. It would be a great help.
 
  • #6
f95toli said:
Superconducting generators are not really that much more efficient than conventional generators (which are already very efficient). The main advantage of SC generators is that they can be much smaller and lighter than a copper generator for the same power rating; this is why they might be very useful in places where there is a limited amount of space; for example on ships. Some companies are also trying to use them for wind turbines.

thank you for clearing that up. I read that superconductor generators may efficiency of almost about 100%. Where as with conventional ones we hv somewhere in 80s. If its true, and feasible for huge generations, i thought that would be a massive improvement.
 
  • #7
Tseyrin said:
thank you for clearing that up. I read that superconductor generators may efficiency of almost about 100%. Where as with conventional ones we hv somewhere in 80s. If its true, and feasible for huge generations, i thought that would be a massive improvement.
Well, very big synchronous generators are almost 99% efficient
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #8
zoki85 said:
Well, very big synchronous generators are almost 99% efficient

well, i have read that back in my country, Bhutan, the plants have efficiencies of about 83 to 87%. If replacing those generators by the superconducting generators could really get up the efficiency upto 95 plus. Do u think its worth a dessertation?
also, i read that somewhere in the west they are actually building a hydropower plant with superconducting generators but its quite small scale, less than 200MW. The ones in Bhutan are well above that.
 
  • #9
Tseyrin said:
well, i have read that back in my country, Bhutan, the plants have efficiencies of about 83 to 87%. If replacing those generators by the superconducting generators could really get up the efficiency upto 95 plus. Do u think its worth a dessertation?
also, i read that somewhere in the west they are actually building a hydropower plant with superconducting generators but its quite small scale, less than 200MW. The ones in Bhutan are well above that.
The most efficient are large hydro electric power plants. IIRC, their max efficiency peaks about 93%. Improving generator's efficiency from 98% to near 100% won't improve overall efficiency much. This doesn't mean superconducting generators are not worth considerations! Tasks like reducing size,mass,and heating problems of big generators are very high on the priority list in power engineering.
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #10
zoki85 said:
The most efficient are large hydro electric power plants. IIRC, their max efficiency peaks about 93%. Improving generator's efficiency from 98% to near 100% won't improve overall efficiency much. This doesn't mean superconducting generators are not worth considerations! Tasks like reducing size,mass,and heating problems of big generators are very high on the priority list in power engineering.
what is IIRC? I googled it but couldn't get a satisfactory answer.
 
  • #11
I only know of a single 1.7MW unit HTS generator being made for a hydropower plant in Germany. What could be the reason why such superconducting generators not being employed in larger ones like a 100MW unit?
 
  • #12
Cost of retrofitting, and that greenies would obsolete renewable hydropower in favor of fishes.
 
  • #13
Tseyrin said:
what is IIRC?
"If I recall correctly"
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #14
Doug Huffman said:
Cost of retrofitting, and that greenies would obsolete renewable hydropower in favor of fishes.
I think you you are wrong.
 
  • #15
zoki85 said:
"If I recall correctly"
haha. I thought we were to use only standard acronyms.
I actually came across an iirc in a small generator!
 
  • #16
Tseyrin said:
I only know of a single 1.7MW unit HTS generator being made for a hydropower plant in Germany. What could be the reason why such superconducting generators not being employed in larger ones like a 100MW unit?
This is a new technology using special solutions and materials. High Temperature Superconductivity still means temperatures must be kept well below -100 °C for such machines to work. Units for powers like 100 MW+ are serious things and such technology must be proven first in regard to high reliability.
 
  • Like
Likes Tseyrin
  • #17
zoki85 said:
This is a new technology using special solutions and materials. High Temperature Superconductivity still means temperatures must be kept well below -100 °C for such machines to work. Units for powers like 100 MW+ are serious things and such technology must be proven first in regard to high reliability.
Then its definitely worth a dessertation?
 
  • #18
Tseyrin

in future ... don't start multiple threads on the same topic

cheers
Dave
 

1. What is a superconducting generator?

A superconducting generator is a type of electric generator that uses superconducting materials, such as niobium-titanium or niobium-tin, to produce electricity. These materials have zero electrical resistance when cooled to extremely low temperatures, allowing for efficient and powerful electricity generation.

2. How does a superconducting generator work?

A superconducting generator works by utilizing the phenomenon of superconductivity. When the superconducting material is cooled to its critical temperature, it becomes a superconductor and allows for a large amount of electrical current to flow through it without any resistance. This current is then used to power the generator and produce electricity.

3. What are the advantages of using a superconducting generator?

Superconducting generators have several advantages over traditional generators. They are more efficient, produce less waste heat, and can handle higher current densities, making them more powerful. They also have a smaller size and weight compared to traditional generators, making them ideal for use in space or for portable power generation.

4. What are the limitations of superconducting generators?

The main limitation of superconducting generators is the need for extremely low temperatures for the superconducting materials to function. This requires a constant supply of liquid helium or other cryogenic fluids, which can be expensive and challenging to maintain. Additionally, the cost of the superconducting materials themselves can be a barrier to widespread use.

5. What are the potential applications of superconducting generators?

Superconducting generators have a wide range of potential applications, including power generation for renewable energy sources such as wind and hydro power, as well as in the aerospace industry for spacecraft and satellites. They also have potential uses in medical imaging, high-speed trains, and particle accelerators.

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
1
Views
173
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
857
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
833
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
814
Replies
34
Views
2K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
956
Back
Top