Symmetry breaking, what is it?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of symmetry breaking, particularly in relation to the Higgs mechanism. It is described as a process where a potential energy term contains false vacuum parts, leading to the formation of bubbles of true vacuum. This concept is then linked to the idea of space tearing and a possible connection between the Higgs mechanism and space tearing is mentioned. The conversation also touches on the question of whether it is an abuse of language to refer to a topological property that applies to all of normal space but not to the true vacuum. Suggestions for further research are also provided.
  • #1
Mike2
1,313
0
What is this symmetry breaking process I keep hearing about?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
Thanks for that link, a good summary without getting technical.

I'm particularly interested in symmetries that are broken to produce mass. I think this involves the "Higgs mechanism", but I'm not sure.

Have symmetries principles been reduced to topological properties of spacetime?

Or would topological properties that apply everywhere except at a certain "boundary" qualify as a symmetry breaking principle?

Thanks.
 
  • #4
The Anderson-Higgs mechanism does indeed involve spontaneously broken symmetry.

The gist of it is, in the elementary Higgs lagrangian, there is a spontaneously broken SO(2) rotational symmetry that goes into a U(1) local gauge symmetry. The thing is there is a strange mixing gauge term that doesn't seem to go away in the original lagrangian, but under the symmetry breaking condition it couples to the Goldstone boson term.. The gauge field is then said to have acquired mass.

With a clever choice of gauge fixing, the original lagrangian, perturbed around the newly inspired ground state now has a massive field.

I wouldn't necessarily call it a topological event *abus de language* perse, its just that the naive form of the potential term contains false vacuum parts, local minima that are not necessarily global. Think of the usual mexican hat potential.

That sort of simplistic example motivates the actual SDM Higgs theories, though the actual nature of the higgs is not known since it has never been observed. Usually in those simple theories, its taken to be a scalar field. In more complicated theories, it can be different (though the remnants often ends up looking like the simple theory + other stuff).
 
  • #5
Haelfix said:
The Anderson-Higgs mechanism does indeed involve spontaneously broken symmetry.
...
I wouldn't necessarily call it a topological event *abus de language* perse, its just that the naive form of the potential term contains false vacuum parts, local minima that are not necessarily global. Think of the usual mexican hat potential.
...

I'd like to quote from ranyart's second link: "After a time the Higgs fields started to decay, to change from zero to non-zero values. This is called spontaneous symmetry breaking. Bubbles of true vacuum (that is, totally empty regions) appeared inside the false vacuum of the Macrocosmos as the symmetry of the fields was spontaneously broken. Within each bubble the Higgs fields spontaneously took on unpredictable values. Inflation continued for a while within each bubble as it moved from the false to the true vacuum."


"true vacuum,... false vacuum"... intriguing. "bubbles of true vacuum" certainly sounds like "space tearing" and forming some sort of boundary to normal space that is then interpreted as resulting in mass, does it not? Is there any mention made about a possible connection between the Higgs mechanism and space tearing? I don't remember where I heard about space tearing, but it was back in the mid to late 80's, if I recall.

My second question was whether it was an abuse of language to call some topological property that applies to all of normal space (the false vacuum) but does not apply for the true vacuum. Is symmetry broken at the boundary between them. I'm thinking of points in normal space being elements of an open neighborhood, but points on the boundary being elements of a half open set. I think that's the verbage for this.

Comments welcome. Thanks.
 
  • #6
Mike2 said:
I'd like to quote from ranyart's second link: "After a time the Higgs fields started to decay, to change from zero to non-zero values. This is called spontaneous symmetry breaking. Bubbles of true vacuum (that is, totally empty regions) appeared inside the false vacuum of the Macrocosmos as the symmetry of the fields was spontaneously broken. Within each bubble the Higgs fields spontaneously took on unpredictable values. Inflation continued for a while within each bubble as it moved from the false to the true vacuum."


"true vacuum,... false vacuum"... intriguing. "bubbles of true vacuum" certainly sounds like "space tearing" and forming some sort of boundary to normal space that is then interpreted as resulting in mass, does it not? Is there any mention made about a possible connection between the Higgs mechanism and space tearing? I don't remember where I heard about space tearing, but it was back in the mid to late 80's, if I recall.

My second question was whether it was an abuse of language to call some topological property that applies to all of normal space (the false vacuum) but does not apply for the true vacuum. Is symmetry broken at the boundary between them. I'm thinking of points in normal space being elements of an open neighborhood, but points on the boundary being elements of a half open set. I think that's the verbage for this.

Comments welcome. Thanks.

Firstly if I make any comments it will be my personal understanding, and as I am un-qualified I will refrain from doing so.

What I will tell you that you need to go google and Xarchive some of Andre Linde's papers, he has is own theory of course, but has slightly more Qualifications than I :redface:
 

1. What is symmetry breaking?

Symmetry breaking is a concept in physics and mathematics where a system that exhibits symmetry at a macroscopic level appears to lose that symmetry at a microscopic level. This phenomenon occurs when a force or influence causes the system to choose one particular state or direction over another, breaking the symmetry of the system.

2. How does symmetry breaking occur?

Symmetry breaking can occur in a variety of ways, depending on the system. In physics, it can occur through the Higgs mechanism, where the Higgs field gives particles mass and breaks the symmetry between different types of particles. In mathematics, it can occur through the spontaneous breaking of a continuous symmetry, where the system settles into one of many possible states.

3. What is the significance of symmetry breaking?

Symmetry breaking is significant because it helps explain how the universe and its laws are structured. It plays a crucial role in particle physics, cosmology, and condensed matter physics, helping scientists understand the fundamental forces and interactions that govern our world.

4. Can symmetry breaking be reversed?

In some cases, symmetry breaking can be reversed. For example, in phase transitions, a system can undergo a reverse symmetry breaking when conditions change. However, in other cases, such as the Higgs mechanism, symmetry breaking is irreversible.

5. How is symmetry breaking related to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking?

Symmetry breaking is closely related to spontaneous symmetry breaking, as it is a type of spontaneous symmetry breaking. The term "spontaneous" refers to the fact that the system chooses one particular state without any external influence. This occurs when the potential energy of the system is minimized, leading to a stable state with broken symmetry.

Similar threads

  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
11
Views
840
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
3
Replies
73
Views
5K
Back
Top